Sunday, July 30, 2023

New Issue: The Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals

The latest issue of The Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals (Vol. 22, no. 2, 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Symposium: Public Interest Litigation at the International Court of Justice
    • Cecily Rose, Introduction
    • Jane A. Hofbauer, Not Just a Participation Trophy? Advancing Public Interests through Advisory Opinions at the International Court of Justice
    • Brian McGarry, Obligations Erga Omnes (Partes) and the Participation of Third States in Inter-State Litigation
    • Nataša Nedeski, Tom Sparks, & Gleider Hernández, The World Is Burning, Urgently and Irreparably – a Plea for Interim Protection against Climatic Change at the ICJ
  • Articles
    • Ivo Tarik de Vries-Zou, An Innovation in the Test for Material Jurisdiction under Certain Compromissory Clauses
    • Janneke Gerards, Moving Away from Open Judicial Balancing Review: The European Court of Human Rights’ Approach as Illustrated by Its Case Law Relevant to the Covid-19 Pandemic
    • Patrick Dumberry, “Cross Treaty Interpretation” en bloc or How CAFTA-DR Tribunals Are Systematically Interpreting the FET Standard Based on NAFTA Case Law
    • Giorgio Sacerdoti, Adjudication of International Trade Disputes: From Success to Crisis. What’s Next?

New Issue: International Criminal Law Review

The latest issue of the International Criminal Law Review (Vol. 23, no. 3, 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Special Issue: Power and Brokerage in International Criminal Justice
    • Mikkel Jarle Christensen & Nabil M. Orina, Power and Brokerage in International Criminal Justice
    • Kyra Wigard, Matter of Opinion: Assessing the Role of Individual Judicial Opinions at the International Criminal Court
    • Nicola Palmer & Tomas Hamilton, Legal Humility and Perceptions of Power in International Criminal Justice
    • Zuzanna Godzimirska & Nabil M. Orina, Scapegoats and Underdogs: Narrative Control and Defence Positioning within and Beyond the International Criminal Court
    • Mikkel Jarle Christensen, Capital and Brokerage in International Criminal Justice: Elite Power in and at the Border of the Field

Saturday, July 29, 2023

Call for Papers: International Security in Cyberspace

A call for papers has been issued for a conference on "International Security in Cyberspace," to be held November 30-December 1, 2023, at the Universidad de Granada. The call is here.

Friday, July 28, 2023

Labuda: Countering Imperialism in International Law: Examining the Special Tribunal for Aggression against Ukraine through a Post-Colonial Eastern European Lens

Patryk I. Labuda (Univ. of Zurich - Law) has posted Countering Imperialism in International Law: Examining the Special Tribunal for Aggression against Ukraine through a Post-Colonial Eastern European Lens (Yale Journal of International Law, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
While Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine has been met with condemnation, the proposed Special Tribunal for Aggression has received mixed reactions. Eastern European states support aggression prosecutions of the Russian leadership, Western powers are cautious, while parts of the non-Western world seem concerned about double standards in the enforcement of international criminal law. By adopting a post-colonial, Eastern European perspective, this article assesses the arguments for and against the establishment of a special tribunal. It foregrounds Ukraine’s history of foreign subjugation to illuminate the counter-hegemonic potential of aggression prosecutions and argues that Russia’s ‘de-Nazification’ rhetoric speaks in favor of a reckoning with Nuremberg’s distorted legacy and neo-imperial phantasies of a ‘Russkiy mir’. The article nuances critiques of selectivity that overlook Ukraine’s liminal place in the global order as a post-colonial state straddling boundaries between North and South, East and West, Europe and Asia. By emphasizing small and weak states’ advocacy for the criminalization of aggression before and after 2022, it suggests that the tribunal may provide inspiration for anti-imperial and counter-hegemonic struggles in other parts of the world, while decolonizing thinking about the Soviet Union’s benevolent role in the Second World War and the Cold War. Against the backdrop of ‘mental maps’ of Eastern Europe and the ‘semi-peripheral’ status of the ‘Global East’ in the global order, the article considers also why Ukraine has embraced international law as an emancipatory tool in its struggle against Russia, and how this relates to Eastern European states’ advocacy of an ‘international’ over a ‘hybrid’ tribunal. In conclusion, Eastern European states are encouraged to embrace the counter-hegemonic aspirations of other weaker states in the global order.

New Issue: Humanity

The latest issue of Humanity (Vol. 14, no. 1, Spring 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Meredith Terretta, Human Rights, Revolutionary Humanitarianism, and African Liberation In 1970: Unsettling Discontinuities in Human Rights History
  • Rohit De, The Jurisprudence of Decolonization: The Postcolonial Career of D. N. Pritt and the Labor of Insurgent Lawyering
  • Andrew Ivaska, Learning from Dar Es Salaam: Harvard’s “Project Tanganyika” And A Nodal Perspective on Decolonization’s Itineraries
  • Joshua Mentanko, The Limits of Pharmaceutical Internationalism: Mexico, the Third World, and The Resource of Medicinal Plants in the 1970s
  • Jessica Lynne Pearson, Decolonizing the Sky: Global Air Travel at the End of Empire
  • Robert A. Karl, Sovereignty Beyond Decolonization: Post-Imperial British Policing and Colombian Criminal Justice, C. 1960–1975
  • Charlotte Kiechel & Zaib un Nisa Aziz, Global History And Decolonization: A Moment Of Possibility, A Call For Integration
  • Ntina Tzouvala, The “Unwilling or Unable” Doctrine and the Political Economy of the War on Terror
  • Nicole Georges, Force-Feeding and “The Right to Maim”: Hunger Strikes at Guantánamo Bay

Thursday, July 27, 2023

New Issue: American Journal of International Law

The latest issue of the American Journal of International Law (Vol. 117, no. 3, July 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Articles
    • Jean Galbraith, Latifa AlMarri, Lisha Bhati, Rheem Brooks, Zachary Green, Margo Hu, & Noor Irshaidat, Poverty Penalties as Human Rights Problems
    • Eileen Denza & Lauge Poulsen, Settling Russia's Imperial and Baltic Debts
  • Editorial Comments
    • Leila Nadya Sadat, In Memoriam: The Late Benjamin B. Ferencz
    • Matiangai Sirleaf, Rendering Whiteness Visible
  • International Decisions
    • Julien Chaisse & Kehinde Folake Olaoye, United States—Origin Marking Requirement, WT/DS597/R
    • Faith O. Majekolagbe, Society of Composers, Authors and Music Publishers of Canada v. Entertainment Software Association
  • Contemporary Practice of the United States Relating to International Law
    • President Biden Issues Conventional Arms Transfer Policy That Emphasizes Human Rights Considerations
    • President Biden Issues Policy on Promoting Accountability for Conflict-Related Sexual Violence
    • The United States Arrests and Charges Eleven in Connection with the Assassination of Haiti's President
    • The United States Promotes Individual Criminal Accountability for Aggression and Atrocity Crimes Committed by Russians in Ukraine
    • The United States Accuses Russia of Not Complying with New START Treaty and Russia Suspends Its Participation
    • The Biden Administration Takes Actions to Restructure Migration to the U.S.-Mexico Border
  • Recent Books on International Law
    • Olabisi D. Akinkugbe, Race & International Investment Law: On the Possibility of Reform and Non-retrenchment
    • Tommaso Soave, reviewing International Law's Invisible Frames: Social Cognition and Knowledge Production in International Legal Processes, edited by Andrea Bianchi and Moshe Hirsch
    • Larissa van den Herik, reviewing Preparing for War: The Making of the Geneva Conventions, by Boyd van Dijk

Evans & Ioannides: The International Court of Justice and the Law of the Sea Dispute Settlement System

Malcolm Evans (Univ. of Oxford - Regent's Park College) & Nicholas A. Ioannides (Univ. of Cyprus - Law) have posted The International Court of Justice and the Law of the Sea Dispute Settlement System (in Research Handbook on the International Court of Justice, Achilles Skordas & Lisa Mardikian eds., forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
This chapter explores aspects of the contribution of the ICJ to the law of the sea dispute settlement system. It is not possible to do so without setting out, albeit briefly, the nature of the contribution which the ICJ has made to the substantive development of the law of the sea more generally since this, it is suggested, still colours its somewhat proprietorial approach towards it. The bulk of the chapter is, however, devoted to considering the interaction between the ICJ, ITLOS and arbitration through a variety of lenses, both procedural and substantive. There are many other points of intersection between the ITLOS and the ICJ in addition to the substantive provisions of the LOSC, and the ITLOS has relied on the ICJ’s jurisprudence with respect to a broad variety of questions, including the definition of a dispute, exhaustion of local remedies, reparation, use of force, the relation between domestic and international law and much else besides. There will, therefore, be many borrowings and potential tensions. However, there is a need for a subject focus, and that chosen is contemporary challenges posed by the increased interest in delimitation beyond 200 nm and unilateral activities in undelimited maritime areas which have in recent times been considered by the ICJ, by ITLOS and by Arbitral Tribunals, the overall focus being on the role, function and contribution of the ICJ to the overall efficacy of dispute settlement within the law of the sea.

Wednesday, July 26, 2023

Conference: Alternative Dispute Resolution in International and EU Law - Recent Trends

On November 16, 2023, the University of Ferrara will host the 5th Biennial Conference of the Italian Branch of the International Law Association. The theme is: "Alternative Dispute Resolution in International and EU Law - Recent Trends." Program and registration are here.

Tuesday, July 25, 2023

Evans & Lewis: Islands, Law and Context: The Treatment of Islands in International Law

Malcolm D. Evans
(Univ. of Oxford) & Reece Lewis (Cardiff Univ. - Law) have published Islands, Law and Context: The Treatment of Islands in International Law (Edward Elgar Publishing 2023). This is a volume in the Elgar International Law series. Here's the abstract:
This ground-breaking book challenges legal orthodoxy, presenting an original approach to the treatment of islands in international law. It offers a new perspective on how to define islands in international law, questioning how they differ from other maritime features. It focuses on the contextual factors that bear upon the legal treatment of islands, recognising that, in practice, islands have varied and unequal impacts and arguing that greater focus on context is needed to understand legal outcomes, particularly those concerning maritime boundary delimitation. Addressing the impact of rising sea levels on the interests and rights of islands and the increasing construction of artificial islands, the authors make the case for a major change in approach to the topic.

Monday, July 24, 2023

Jankauskas & Eckhard: The Politics of Evaluation in International Organizations

Vytautas Jankauskas
(Zeppelin Univ.) & Steffen Eckhard (Zeppelin Univ.) have published The Politics of Evaluation in International Organizations (Oxford Univ. Press 2023). Here's the abstract:

Evaluation has become a key tool in assessing the performance of international organizations, in fostering learning, and in demonstrating accountability. Within the United Nations (UN) system, thousands of evaluators and consultants produce hundreds of evaluation reports worth millions of dollars every year. But does evaluation really deliver on its promise of objective evidence and functional use?

By unravelling the internal machinery of evaluation systems in international organizations, this book challenges the conventional understanding of evaluation as a value-free activity. Vytautas Jankauskas and Steffen Eckhard show how a seemingly neutral technocratic tool can serve as an instrument for power in global governance; they demonstrate and explain how deeply politics are entrenched in the interests of evaluation stakeholders, in the control and design of IO evaluation systems, and to a lesser extent also in the content of evaluation reports. The analysis draws on 120 research interviews with evaluators, member state representatives, and IO secretariat officials as well as on textual analysis of over 200 evaluation reports. The investigation covers 21 UN system organizations, including detailed case studies of the ILO, IMF, UNDP, UN WOMEN, IOM, UNHCR, FAO, WHO, and UNESCO.

Shedding light on the (in-)effectiveness of evidence-based policymaking, the authors propose possible ways of better reconciling the observed evaluation politics with the need to gather reliable evidence that is used to improve the functioning of the United Nations. The answer to evaluation politics is not to abandon evaluation or isolate it from the stakeholders but to acknowledge surrounding political interests and design evaluation systems accordingly.

Wheeler: Fairness and the Goals of International Criminal Trials: Finding a Balance

Caleb H Wheeler
(Cardiff Univ. - Law) has published Fairness and the Goals of International Criminal Trials: Finding a Balance (Routledge 2023). Here's the abstract:
This book presents a ground-breaking, interdisciplinary study into the various goals assigned to international criminal trials. It starts from the proposition that no hierarchy exists amongst the different goals meaning that trials should strive to achieve all of them in equal measure. This is made difficult by the fact that not all of these goals are compatible and the fulfilment of one may lead to others going unmet. Therefore, a balance must be found if the goals of trial are to be achieved at all. The book posits that fairness should serve as the guiding principle when weighing the different trial goals against one another. It is argued that without fairness international and internationalised criminal courts and tribunals lack legitimacy and without legitimacy they lack effectiveness. The book concludes that international criminal trials must adopt procedures that emphasise fairness to all of the parties and trial participants if they wish to accomplish any of the goals set for them. Each chapter is devoted to identifying and explaining a different trial goal, providing analysis of how that particular goal functions in conjunction with the other goals, and discussing the ways in which a fairness-oriented trial model will help achieve those goals. The book provides a dynamic understanding of the different trial goals and the importance of fairness in the trial process by drawing on research from a variety of different legal disciplines while also incorporating scholarship rooted in criminology, political theory, international relations, and psychology.

Wierda: The Local Impact of the International Criminal Court: From Law to Justice

Marieke Wierda
has published The Local Impact of the International Criminal Court: From Law to Justice (Cambridge Univ. Press 2023). Here's the abstract:
The International Criminal Court seeks to end impunity for the world's worst crimes, to contribute to their prevention. But what is its impact to date? This book takes an in-depth look at four countries under scrutiny of the ICC: Afghanistan, Colombia, Libya, and Uganda. It puts forward an analytical framework to assess the impact of the ICC on four levels: on the domestic legal systems (systemic effect); on peace negotiations and agreements (transformative effect); on victims (reparative effect); and on the perceptions of affected populations (demonstration effect). It concludes that the ICC is having a normative impact on domestic legal systems and peace agreements, but it has brought little reparative justice for victims, and it does not necessarily correspond with how affected populations view justice priorities. The book concludes that justice for the world's worst crimes has no 'universal formula' that can easily be captured in law by one institution.

Saturday, July 22, 2023

Lagrange & Dubin: Les inégalités et leurs manifestations en droit international

Evelyne Lagrange
(Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne) & Laurence Dubin (Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne) have published Les inégalités et leurs manifestations en droit international (Pedone 2023). The table of contents is here. Here's the abstract:

Inégalité. La notion peut sembler à la fois commune et fuyante, le phénomène peut sembler objectivé, puisque quantifiable, mais subjectif selon la perception de chacun (peut-être elle-même socialement déterminée). Pourtant, un constat s’impose : les inégalités sont partout, protéiformes (de revenu, d’accès au droit, d’accès aux services de base, à l’éducation, à la reconnaissance…) et multifactorielles (liées au genre, à l’origine sociale, à la résidence, intersectionnelles, etc.) ; elles se laissent mesurer et comparer au plan national, européen et international ; elles peuvent être freinées, simplement permises, ou favorisées voire amplifiées, objectivement ou par suite d’un calcul assumé, par les institutions juridiques internationales et européennes.

Egalité, disparités, inégalités, discriminations… Comment ces notions sont-elles construites et définies en droit international et européen, dans leurs deux dimensions, publique comme privée ? Comment s’opère le passage de l’une à l’autre et des notions ou des principes politiques aux principes de droit ? Comment expliquer et peut-être corriger des constructions qui, sous le fronton du principe d’égalité, organisent et codifient des inégalités ou les ignorent et les rejettent dans un autre ordre juridique ?

Le présent ouvrage, issu d’une Journée d’étude du Département de droit international et européen de l’Ecole de droit de la Sorbonne, regroupe les contributions originales de doctorants en droit international public, privé et européen sur les concepts et les principes, les inégalités dans les relations entre Etats, les inégalités dans les pratiques institutionnelles et juridictionnelles et les vulnérabilités dans la pratique juridique.

Lifshits: Tax Competence of the Eurasian Economic Union: A New Reading by the Court

Ilya Lifshits (Russian Foreign Trade Academy – Law) has published Tax Competence of the Eurasian Economic Union: A New Reading by the Court (Nuovi Autoritarismi e Democrazie: Diritto, Istituzioni, Società, Vol. 5, no. 1, 2023). Here's the abstract:
In October 2022, the Court of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) adopted the first Advisory Opinion fully devoted to the interpretation of the tax provisions of the EAEU Treaty. While reiterating its previous findings that the powers to impose taxes fall within the jurisdiction of the Member States, for the first time, the Court has argued in favour of limiting these powers by the law of the EAEU. Such limitations derive from the principles of non-discrimination and free competition of goods and services regardless of the country of production. In such a manner, the Court has made a significant contribution to the establishment of a single common market within the Union and has enriched the understanding of the principles governing the division of competence between the Member States and the bodies of the Union. The only conclusion that could be seen as dubious by the Court was regarding the collection of VAT on the basis of the country of destination and the fact that this is necessary to maintain competition and avoid double taxation and that the reasoning for such a mechanism is also predetermined by the nature of this tax.

Daase, Deitelhoff, & Witt: Rule in International Politics

Christopher Daase
(Goethe Univ. Frankfurt), Nicole Deitelhoff (Goethe Univ. Frankfurt), & Antonia Witt (Peace Research Institute Frankfurt) have published Rule in International Politics (Cambridge Univ. Press 2023). The table of contents is here. Here's the abstract:
There is hardly any aspect of social, political, and economic life today that is not also governed internationally. Drawing on debates around hierarchy, hegemony, and authority in international politics, this volume takes the study of the international 'beyond anarchy' a step further by establishing the concept of rule as the defining feature of order in the international realm. The contributors argue that the manifold conceptual approaches to sub- and superordination in the international should be understood as rich conceptualizations of one concept: rule. Rule allows constellations of sub- and superordination in the international to be seen as multiplex, systemic, and normatively ambiguous phenomena that need to be studied in the context of their interplay and consequences. This volume draws on a variety of conceptualizations of rule, exploring, in particular, the practices of rule as well as the relational and dynamic characteristics of rule in international politics.

New Issue: Journal of World Intellectual Property

The latest issue of the Journal of World Intellectual Property (Vol. 26, no. 2, July 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Articles
    • Sherin Priyan & Gouri Gargate, Patent pools and innovation-based approach in global healthcare crisis
    • Tasya S. Ramli, Ahmad M. Ramli, Ranti F. Mayana, Ega Ramadayanti, & Rizki Fauzi, Artificial intelligence as object of intellectual property in Indonesian law
    • Which mode of governance for the innovation cities of Moroccan public universities? Hanane Nahid, Yassine Marzougui
    • Brigitte Tenni, Joel Lexchin, Sovath Phin, Chalermsak Kittitrakul, & Deborah Gleeson, Lessons from India and Thailand for Cambodia's future implementation of the TRIPS Agreement for pharmaceutical patents
    • Mrityunjay Kumar & Nalin Bharti, Why patent waiver for Covid-19 vaccines and pharmaceuticals?
    • Adnan Jashari & Stefani Stojchevska, Intellectual property rights in outer space: How can pharmaceutical companies protect COVID-19 vaccine and immunotherapy developments aboard the ISS US national laboratory?
    • Oluwaseun S. Fapetu, A re-examination of the plant variety act 2021 from the perspective of pre-exisiting obligation to protect plant varieties
    • Ma Biyu & Yu Dingming, Other options to resolve patent infringement dispute, experiences from China

Friday, July 21, 2023

Meyer: Consumption Governance: The Role of Production and Consumption in International Economic Law

Timothy Meyer (Duke Univ. - Law) has posted Consumption Governance: The Role of Production and Consumption in International Economic Law (Brigham Young University Law Review, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:

Over the last decade, international economic conflict has increased dramatically. To name only a few examples, the European Union has banned the import of products from deforested land and is poised to impose a duties on carbon-intensive imports; the United States has banned imports from China made with forced labor; and countries the world over threated to impose digital services taxes on U.S. corporations, leading to a new multilateral agreement on apportioning income tax revenue among countries. The Article argues that these conflicts are explained by a shift in the norms governing authority to tax and regulate international commerce. Different fields within international economic law describe the limits of state authority to tax and regulate in very different ways. But I argue that a trans-substantive set of principles underlies the varied doctrines in international trade, international tax, and international antitrust. Specifically, throughout the twentieth century, international law’s limits on jurisdiction rested at bottom on the notion that production could be taxed and regulated primarily and often only by the country in which production occurred (what this Article terms “production jurisdiction”). Today, by contrast, nations increasingly claim jurisdiction to tax and regulate production that occurs overseas based on their interest in controlling the kinds of activity that consumption within their borders supports (what this Article terms “consumption jurisdiction”).

I make three contributions. First, I describe the ongoing shift from production jurisdiction to consumption jurisdiction. In so doing, I explain that the diverse doctrines limiting state authority in international antitrust law, international tax, and international trade, are really part of a single overarching approach to jurisdiction and that disruptive policies within each of these issue areas can be tied to the change in that approach.

Second, I argue that the shift from production to consumption jurisdiction does not mean the end of globalization or the rise of protectionism. Rather, it reflects a change in states’ views as to whether national policies should be part of a nation’s comparative advantage in the global economy. Under production jurisdiction, producing nations could set policies to support export-oriented growth and consuming nations were largely disabled from taxing and regulating on the basis of productive activities that occurred overseas. Under consumption jurisdiction, nations can condition market access on compliance with the consuming nations’ policies on production, thus negating any advantage nations might confer on their producers via low levels of tax and regulation. As such, consumption jurisdiction is consistent with an open global economy, but one in which nations can choose what kinds of activities their consumption supports.

Third, I discuss the implications of the shift from production to consumption jurisdiction. I highlight three points. First, consumption jurisdiction creates concurrent jurisdiction, whereas production jurisdiction grants one country primary authority. In a globalized economy, concurrent consumption jurisdiction is more likely to lead to a race to the top in tax and regulation, whereas production jurisdiction is more likely to lead to a race to the bottom. Second, the shift to consumption jurisdiction is likely to have negative distributional implications for small and developing economies. Third, and counterintuitively, well-institutionalized areas of the law like international trade have struggled to adjust to new jurisdiction rules, while more thinly institutionalized areas, such as competition law and tax, have seen relatively less conflict.

Thursday, July 20, 2023

New Issue: Review of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law

The latest issue of the Review of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law (Vol. 32, no. 2, July 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Special Issue: International Climate Litigation
    • Benoit Mayer & Harro van Asselt, The rise of international climate litigation
    • Daniel Bodansky, Advisory opinions on climate change: Some preliminary questions
    • Aref Shams, Tempering great expectations: The legitimacy constraints and the conflict function of international courts in international climate litigation
    • Yoshifumi Tanaka, The role of an advisory opinion of ITLOS in addressing climate change: Some preliminary considerations on jurisdiction and admissibility
    • Rozemarijn J. Roland Holst, Taking the current when it serves: Prospects and challenges for an ITLOS advisory opinion on oceans and climate change
    • Leslie-Anne Duvic-Paoli & Mario Gervasi, Harm to the global commons on trial: The role of the prevention principle in international climate adjudication
    • Christina Voigt, The power of the Paris Agreement in international climate litigation
    • Natalie Jones, Prospects for invoking the law of self-determination in international climate litigation
    • Steve Lorteau, The potential of international ‘State-as-polluter’ litigation
    • Riccardo Luporini & Annalisa Savaresi, International human rights bodies and climate litigation: Don't look up?
    • Armando Rocha & Rômulo Sampaio, Climate change before the European and Inter-American Courts of Human Rights: Comparing possible avenues before human rights bodies
    • Kári Ragnarsson, What can climate change litigation learn from socio-economic rights litigation?
    • Shalini Iyengar, Human rights and climate wrongs: Mapping the landscape of rights-based climate litigation
    • Chiara Tea Antoniazzi, Strengthening the complaint mechanisms of multilateral climate funds and carbon markets: A critical step towards a human rights-based green transition
    • Henok Asmelash, The WTO dispute settlement system as a forum for climate litigation?
    • Diego Mejía-Lemos, The suitability of investor-State dispute settlement and host State counterclaims for implementing climate change international responsibility
    • Ji Ma, Bridging multinational corporations' investment-climate gap: Prospects for the direct claims approach
    • Oliver Hailes, Unjust enrichment in investor–State arbitration: A principled limit on compensation for future income from fossil fuels
  • Case Note
    • Tadesse M. Kebebew, Dispute over the Status and Use of the Waters of the Silala (Chile v Bolivia): Is the International Court of Justice falling short?

New Issue: International Community Law Review

The latest issue of the International Community Law Review (Vol. 25, nos. 3-4, 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Special Issue: Sustainable Development, Business and Human Rights: A Comparative Study
    • Dalia Palombo, The US at the Margins of Business and Human Rights
    • Pauline Martini & María Paula López Velásquez, Holding Corporations Liable for Breaches of Indigenous Peoples’ Right to a Healthy Environment in Colombia: Chimera or Reality?
    • Matthieu Burnay & Bin Li, Chinese Perspectives on Sustainable Development: Discourses and Practices at National and International Levels
    • Ludovica Chiussi Curzi, Climate Change and its ‘Grotian’ Effects on a Principle of Corporate Liability in International Law
    • Jacinta Studdert, Valencia Govender, Johann Spies, Marta Jarque Branguli, Sofia Nievas, Maria Fernanda Roca Silva, Wen Zhu, Pryderi Diebschlag, Remi Sassine, Wim Cilliers, Kate Swart, Milena Szuniewicz-Wenzel, Sarah Hill-Smith, Saskia Wolters, & Catherine Wang, Corporate Due Diligence and Reporting Requirements for Climate Change and Human Rights

New Issue: Nordic Journal of International Law

The latest issue of the Nordic Journal of International Law (Vol. 92, no. 2, 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Tom Allen & Jan Mikael Lundmark, Norwegian Law and the Swedish Sami: Rights, Paternalism and International Law
  • Alison Bisset, The Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty for Core Crimes: A Project in Need of Purpose
  • Isak Nilsson, On the Path to Universalism? The Role of External Instruments in the European Court of Human Rights Jurisprudence
  • José María Lorenzo Villaverde, The Danish Rigsfællesskab: A Decentralised State Which is Not Fully Aware of Being One

New Issue: Transnational Environmental Law

The latest issue of Transnational Environmental Law (Vol. 12, no. 2, July 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Editorial
    • Thijs Etty, Josephine van Zeben, Cinnamon Carlarne, Leslie-Anne Duvic-Paoli, Bruce Huber, & Leonie Reins, The Methodologies of Transnational Environmental Law Scholarship
  • Articles
    • Yoshifumi Tanaka, Shared State Responsibility for Land-Based Marine Plastic Pollution
    • Laura Kaschny, Energy Justice and the Principles of Article 194(1) TFEU Governing EU Energy Policy
    • Eva van der Zee, Strengthening Environmental Decision Making through Legislation: Insights from Cognitive Science and Behavioural Economics
    • J. Michael Angstadt, Can Domestic Environmental Courts Implement International Environmental Law? A Framework for Institutional Analysis
    • David J. Jefferson, Elizabeth Macpherson, & Steven Moe, Experiments with the Extension of Legal Personality to Ecosystems and Beyond-Human Organisms: Challenges and Opportunities for Company Law
    • Craig M. Kauffman & Pamela L. Martin, How Ecuador's Courts Are Giving Form and Force to Rights of Nature Norms
    • Ying Xia & Yueduan Wang, An Unlikely Duet: Public-Private Interaction in China's Environmental Public Interest Litigation
    • Shawkat Alam, Laely Nurhidayah, & Michelle Lim, Towards a Transnational Approach to Transboundary Haze Pollution: Governing Traditional Farming in Fire-Prone Regions of Indonesia

Wednesday, July 19, 2023

New Issue: Climate Law

The latest issue of Climate Law (Vol. 13, no. 1, 2023) is out. Contents include:
  • Benjamin J. Richardson & Sarah Castles-Lynch, Trying to Express Climate Concerns through Environmental Law? The Changing Lawscape of Public Participation
  • Felicity Deane & Callum Brockett, Carbon Border Adjustments: A Legal Tool for Mitigation or a Barrier to Justice?
  • Benoit Mayer, Can Rights-Based Litigation Bolster Climate Action?

Milanovic: Revisiting Coercion as an Element of Prohibited Intervention in International Law

Marko Milanovic (Univ. of Reading - Law) has posted Revisiting Coercion as an Element of Prohibited Intervention in International Law (American Journal of International Law, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:

International law prohibits States from intervening in the internal and external affairs of other States, but only if the method of intervention is coercive. Building on recent developments in State practice, especially in the cyber context, this article argues that coercion can be understood in two different ways or models. First, as coercion-as-extortion, a demand coupled with a threat of harm or the infliction of harm, done to extract some kind of concession from the victim State – in other words, an act targeting the victim State’s will or decision-making calculus. Second, as coercion-as-control, an act depriving the victim State of its ability to control its sovereign choices.

The article argues that many of the difficulties surrounding the notion of coercion arise as a consequence of failing to distinguish between these two different models. Coercion-as-extortion consists of imposing costs on the victim State, so as to cause it to change its policy choices. This is precisely how coercion has traditionally been understood in this context, as “dictatorial” intervention. Coercion-as-control, by contrast, is not about affecting the victim State’s decision-making calculus – the victim State’s leadership may even be entirely unaware of the actions taken against it – but consists of a material constraint on its ability to pursue the choices that it wanted to pursue. Consider here, for example, a cyber operation against the elections in another country, which may be entirely unrelated to any demands or threats by the coercing State.

In developing these two models of coercion the article extensively discusses the role of intention in coercion and the possible approaches to conceptualizing the threshold of harm. It also explains how debates on coercion in the non-intervention context have been shaped by the problem of justification. On one hand there is an intuition that some forms of coercion are justified. On the other hand, the prohibition of intervention is regarded as a categorical rule admitting of no exceptions. This incentivizes approaches that narrow down the scope of prohibited intervention, e.g. through the exclusion of economic measures from the concept of coercion. The article cautions against such moralized conceptions of coercion, arguing that the reserved domain element of prohibited intervention is a better vehicle for accommodating problems of justification. In particular, coercive measures taken to enforce compliance with prior international legal obligations generally cannot constitute prohibited intervention in the internal or external affairs of the target State, although they may violate other rules of international law.

Grandaubert: L’immunité d’exécution de l’état étranger et des organisations internationales en droit international

Victor Grandaubert
has published L’immunité d’exécution de l’état étranger et des organisations internationales en droit international (Pedone 2023). Here's the abstract:

Pour quelle raison les immunités d’exécution de l’État étranger et des organisations internationales résistent-elles fermement au processus d’érosion des immunités internationales ? Selon toute apparence, contrairement à l’immunité de juridiction, l’immunité d’exécution fait échapper ses bénéficiaires à des actes d’une certaine gravité sur leurs biens, à savoir des mesures de contrainte étatique. Ce constat en soi est toutefois insusceptible d’expliquer la solidité commune dont ces immunités font preuve dans un contexte où l’on distingue a priori entre l’immunité souveraine de l’État et les immunités fonctionnelles des organisations internationales.

Pour appréhender précisément la singularité de l’immunité d’exécution, cette thèse démontre que cette immunité tire sa force de son caractère fondamental pour le maintien de l’architecture du droit international. Il n’en demeure pas moins qu’en analysant ainsi l’immunité d’exécution, la thèse contribue à mettre en évidence l’effacement de la distinction communément admise entre les immunités de l’État et celles des organisations internationales.

En effet, l’immunité d’exécution a par essence pour objet d’assurer une protection contre la contrainte étatique, exercée dans un cadre juridictionnel ou non, aux biens employés par des entités agissant librement en qualité de pouvoir public en dehors d’un cadre exclusivement national. Reflet de la stabilité qui caractérise cette immunité en droit international, la protection qu’elle assure en pratique s’inscrit du reste dans un phénomène de consolidation.