Tuesday, June 4, 2019

Krieger & Püschmann: Securing of Resources as a Valid Reason for Using Force? – A Pre-Emptive Defence of the Prohibition on the Use of Force

Heike Krieger (Freie Universitaet Berlin - Law) & Jonas Püschmann (Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law) have posted Securing of Resources as a Valid Reason for Using Force? – A Pre-Emptive Defence of the Prohibition on the Use of Force. Here's the abstract:
A growing demand for natural resources embedded in current changes of the international order will put pressure on states to secure the future availability of these resources. Some political discourses suggest that states might respond by challenging the foundations of international law. Whereas the UN Charter was inter alia aimed at eliminating uses of force for economic reasons, one may observe an on-going trend of securitization of matters of resource supply resulting into the revival of self-preservation doctrines. The chapter will show that those claims lack a normative foundation in the current framework of the prohibition of the use of force. Moreover, international law has sufficient instruments to cope with disputes over access to resources by other means than the use of force. The international community, therefore, must oppose claims that may contribute to normative uncertainties and strengthen already existing instruments of pacific settlement of disputes.

Brunner & Gottlieb: Commentary on the UN Sales Law (CISG)

Christoph Brunner & Benjamin Gottlieb have published Commentary on the UN Sales Law (CISG) (Wolters Kluwer 2019). Here's the abstract:
Buyers and sellers engaging in the cross-border sale of goods are well-advised to be conversant with the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), which governs international sales contracts. The CISG has been ratified by 89 states, which together account for over three-quarters of all world trade. This practically-oriented, article-by-article commentary on the CISG will be useful to legal practitioners, counsel and arbitrators dealing with international sales contracts. The in-depth annotations deal extensively with the legal issues likely to arise under each CISG article. The annotations include up-to-date analyses of state court and arbitral decisions, the legal doctrines derived from these decisions, and relevant scholarship to date. A

Monday, June 3, 2019

Kassoti: Bridge over Troubled Water: Opinion 1/17 and the Autonomy of the EU Legal Order

Eva Kassoti (T.M.C. Asser Instituut) has published Bridge over Troubled Water: Opinion 1/17 and the Autonomy of the EU Legal Order (Revista General de Derecho Europeo, no. 48, May 2019).

La Vaccara: When the conflict ends, while uncertainty continues : accounting for missing persons between war and peace in international law

Alessandra La Vaccara (International Commission on Missing Persons) has published When the conflict ends, while uncertainty continues : accounting for missing persons between war and peace in international law (Pedone 2019). Here's the abstract:
During an armed conflict and in its aftermath, measures must be undertaken in order to ascertain the fate of the missing and to address the emotional distress of families from the lack of news on their relatives. In the same contextual settings, cases of missing persons may involve criminal accountability, thereby triggering actions directed to answer questions like ‘who is responsible?’ and ‘what are the circumstances of the crime?’. These courses of action respond to two different needs, i.e., the need of families to know the fate and whereabouts of their missing relatives, and the societal and individual need for accountability. The book examines how the international legal framework meets these two distinct, but intertwined, needs. It captures the diversity of international rules concerning the issue of persons reported missing in armed conflict, as well as the complexity of their implementation in the transition from an armed conflict to peace. The book shows that the duty to account for missing persons has a temporal cross-cutting nature, since its implementation requires measures before, during, and after an armed conflict. Dealing with the issue of the missing across phases − i.e., durante bello and post bellum − entails a complex interplay of international norms. Affirming the relevance of the dialectic between International Humanitarian Law (IHL) and International Human Rights Law (IHRL) in the transition from conflict to peace, the book analyzes the simultaneous application of IHL and IHRL rules on missing persons in post-conflict and proposes a set of criteria that should govern their interplay. Measures that respond to the right of families to know the fate of their relatives cannot substitute those that are required to establish responsibility for IHL/IHRL violations and international crimes, and vice-versa. Examining specific examples, the book unveils the role that international law plays in the attempts of the international community to articulate humanitarian and accountability-driven efforts vis-à-vis post-conflict claims for information on the missing. In light of this analysis, the book explores the legal and policy aspects of how to build linkages between such efforts.

Sunday, June 2, 2019

Dijkstal: Yemen and the Stockholm Agreement: Background, Context, and the Significance of the Agreement

Haydee Dijkstal has posted an ASIL Insight on Yemen and the Stockholm Agreement: Background, Context, and the Significance of the Agreement.

New Issue: Questions of International Law

The latest issue of Questions of International Law / Questioni di Diritto Internazionale (no. 59, 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • The qualification of armed conflicts and the ‘Support-Based Approach’: Time for an appraisal
    • Introduced by Giulio Bartolini & Marco Pertile
    • Raphaël van Steenberghe and Pauline Lesaffre, The ICRC’s ‘support-based approach’: A suitable but incomplete theory
    • Bianca Maganza, Which role for hybrid entities involved in multi-parties NIACs? Applying the ICRC’s support-based approach to the armed conflict in Mali

Workshop: The Paths of Change in International Law

On June 6-7, 2019, the Paths of International Law Project will hold a workshop on "The Paths of Change in International Law" will take place in Geneva. The program is here.

Conference: Protecting Community Interests under International Law: Challenges and Prospects for the 21st Century

On June 3, 2019, the Norwegian Centre for Human Rights and the Research Group on Human Rights, Armed Conflicts, and the Law of Peace and Security, both at the University of Oslo, will hold a conference on "Protecting Community Interests under International Law: Challenges and Prospects for the 21st Century," in Oslo. The program is here.

New Issue: International Journal of Human Rights

The latest issue of the International Journal of Human Rights (Vol. 23, no. 3, 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • Special Issue: Human Rights Monitoring and Implementation
    • Andressa M. Gadda, Juliet Harris, E. Kay M. Tisdall, Elizabeth Millership & Ursula Kilkelly, Human rights’ monitoring and implementation: how to make rights ‘real’ in children’s lives
    • Ursula Kilkelly, The UN convention on the rights of the child: incremental and transformative approaches to legal implementation
    • Tara M. Collins, The general measures of implementation: opportunities for progress with children’s rights
    • Bronagh Byrne & Laura Lundy, Children’s rights-based childhood policy: a six-P framework
    • Simon Hoffman, The UN convention on the rights of the child, decentralisation and legislative integration: a case study from Wales
    • Andressa M. Gadda, Juliet Harris, E. Kay M. Tisdall & Elizabeth Millership, ‘Making children’s rights real’: lessons from policy networks and Contribution Analysis
    • Lisa Payne, Child Rights Impact Assessment as a policy improvement tool
    • Kasey McCall-Smith, To incorporate the CRC or not – is this really the question?
    • Joel Meekison & Suki Wan, A young person’s guide to defending human rights

Saturday, June 1, 2019

Davitti: Investment and Human Rights in Armed Conflict: Charting an Elusive Intersection

Daria Davitti (Univ. of Nottingham - Law) has published Investment and Human Rights in Armed Conflict: Charting an Elusive Intersection (Hart Publishing 2019). Here's the abstract:
This book analyses the way in which international human rights law (IHRL) and international investment law (IIL) are deployed – or fail to be deployed – in conflict countries within the context of natural resources extraction. It specifically analyses the way in which IIL protections impact on the parallel protection of economic, social and cultural rights (ESC rights) in the host state, especially the right to water. Arguing that current responses have been unsatisfactory, it considers the emergence of the 'Protect, Respect and Remedy' framework and the Guiding Principles for Business and Human Rights (jointly the Framework) as a possible analytical instrument. In so doing, it proposes a different approach to the way in which the Framework is generally interpreted, and then investigates the possible applicability of this 'recalibrated' Framework to the study of the IHRL-IIL interplay in a host country in a protracted armed conflict: Afghanistan. Through the emblematic example of Afghanistan, the book presents a practical dimension to its legal analysis. It uniquely portrays the elusive intersection between these two bodies of international law within a host country where the armed conflict continues to rage and a full economic restructuring is taking place away from the public eye, not least through the deployment of IIL and the inaction – or merely partial consideration – of IHRL. The book will be of interest to academics, policy-makers, and practitioners of international organisations involved in IHRL, IIL and/or deployed in contexts of armed conflict.

Palombino: Duelling for Supremacy: International Law vs. National Fundamental Principles

Fulvio Maria Palombino (Università degli Studi di Napoli 'Federico II' - Law) has published Duelling for Supremacy: International Law vs. National Fundamental Principles (Cambridge Univ. Press 2019). The table of contents is here. Here's the abstract:
It is a settled rule of international law that a State may not rely on the provisions of its 'internal law' as justification for failing to comply with international obligations. However, the judiciaries of most countries, including those with a high record of compliance with international norms, have increasingly felt the need to preserve the area of fundamental principles, where the State's inclination to retain full sovereignty seems to act as an unbreakable 'counter-limit' to the limitations deriving from international law. This volume explores this trend by adopting a comparative perspective, addressing the question of how conflicts between international law and national fundamental principles are dealt with and resolved within a specific legal system. The contributing authors identify common tendencies and fundamental differences in the approaches and evaluate the implications of this practice for the future of the principle of supremacy of international law.

Mukherjee: The “Right to Wage War” against Empire: Anticolonialism and the Challenge to International Law in the Indian National Army Trial of 1945

Mithi Mukherjee (Univ. of Colorado, Boulder - History) has published The “Right to Wage War” against Empire: Anticolonialism and the Challenge to International Law in the Indian National Army Trial of 1945 (Law & Social Inquiry, Vol. 44, no. 2, pp. 420-443, May 2019). Here's the abstract:
This Article treats the Indian National Army Trial of 1945 as a key moment in the elaboration of an anticolonial critique of international law in India. The trial was actually a court-martial of three Indian officers by the British colonial government on charges of high treason for defecting from the British Indian Army, joining up with Indian National Army forces in Singapore, and waging war in alliance with Imperial Japan against the British. In this trial, the defense made the radical claim that anticolonial wars fought in Asia against European powers were legitimate and just and should be recognized as such under international law. The aim of this Article is to draw attention to the understudied role of anticolonial movements in challenging the premises of international law in the aftermath of World War II.

Dannenbaum: War Crimes and Just War Theory

Tom Dannenbaum (Tufts Univ. - Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy) has posted War Crimes and Just War Theory (in The Palgrave Handbook of Applied Ethics and the Criminal Law, Kimberly Kessler Ferzan & Larry Alexander eds., forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
Revisionist just war theory has gained considerable traction in recent years, debunking longstanding principles in the morality of war. This development cannot be ignored by war crimes lawyers. Philosophers on both sides of these debates, as well as many lawyers, understand the attacked principles to provide the moral underpinning of the contemporary war crimes regime. This perceived tension is erroneous. A panoramic view of the applicable law reveals it to be more revisionist in its moral posture than is ordinarily recognized. First, increasing recognition of the applicability of international human rights law in armed conflict reflects growing skepticism of the normative exceptionalism of war. Second, the criminalization of aggression reflects the moral inequality of combatants. Third, the legal distinction between civilians and combatants is understood best through a combination of individual liability and necessity — principles that can be accommodated in more nuanced ways as human rights law gains traction. Gaps remain, but there is more common ground between international law and revisionist theory than either lawyers or theorists tend to recognize.

Friday, May 31, 2019

New Volume: Anuario Español de Derecho Internacional

The latest volume of the Anuario Español de Derecho Internacional (Vol. 35, 2019) is out. The table of contents is here.

Mulesky & Sandholtz: Do Human Rights Treaty Obligations Matter?

Suzie Mulesky (Univ. of Southern California - International Relations) & Wayne Sandholtz (Univ. of Southern California - International Relations) have posted Do Human Rights Treaty Obligations Matter? Here's the abstract:
Why do some human rights treaties receive rapid and near universal commitment from states while others take decades for the majority of states to ratify? Little scholarship to date has analyzed the effects of treaty design, in particular, the substance of treaty obligations, on the likelihood of ratification. We analyze new data that code every provision of ten global human rights treaties for the strength and precision of the obligations they contain. We classify obligations that are strong, precise, and that require domestic action as “demanding.” We hypothesize that treaties containing more of these demanding obligations would be seen as more costly to ratify because they imply potentially greater policy adaptation or compliance costs. Event history analyses are consistent with that hypothesis. The addition of 15 demanding treaty obligations decreases the likelihood of ratification by nearly 20 percent, similar to the effect of moving from democracy to autocracy. This effect is consistent when controlling for various treaty, state, and global level factors that may also influence a state’s decision to ratify.

d'Aspremont: Critical Histories of International Law and the Repression of Disciplinary Imagination

Jean d'Aspremont (Sciences Po - Law; Univ. of Manchester - Law) has posted Critical Histories of International Law and the Repression of Disciplinary Imagination (London Review of International Law, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
This article engages with international lawyers’ growing historiographical appetites. It makes the argument that the critical histories that have come to populate the international legal literature over the last decades continue to be organised along the very lines set by the linear historical narratives which they seek to question and disrupt. It makes a plea for radical historical critique, that is, for critical histories that move beyond the markers, periodisation and causal sequencing they seek to displace or disrupt and that embrace a consciously interventionist history-writing attitude with a view to unbridling disciplinary imagination.

Sinclair: Forging Modern States with Imperfect Tools: United Nations Technical Assistance for Public Administration in Decolonized States

Guy Fiti Sinclair (Victoria Univ. of Wellington - Law) has posted Forging Modern States with Imperfect Tools: United Nations Technical Assistance for Public Administration in Decolonized States (Humanity, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
This article examines United Nations (UN) programs of technical assistance for public administration as a ‘technology of stateness’ during the postwar period of decolonization (roughly 1945-1965). Drawing on the wider modernization and development literature as well as original research in the UN Archives, the article shows how the Public Administration Division of the UN’s Technical Assistance Administration connected with a larger network of actors interested in promoting public administration reforms in decolonized states, including other international organizations, private actors (including charitable foundations and professional associations), state agencies, and national elites. The article further analyzes the rationalities and technologies advanced by UN technical assistance in this field, finding a complex picture whereby the advice given and actions taken by UN officials suggested both a tendency towards centralization of state of power and a movement of power away from the state. In doing so, the article highlights continuities between postwar development and the ‘neoliberal’ practices of development management that emerged towards the end of the twentieth century.

Garcia: Consent and Trade: Trading Freely in a Global Market

Frank J. Garcia (Boston College - Law) has published Consent and Trade: Trading Freely in a Global Market (Cambridge Univ. Press 2019). Here's the abstract:
In a time of changing trade norms, when free trade seems to be giving way to new kinds of nationalism, some fundamental questions about trade are still not being asked. Is trade consensual or coercive? Is 'free trade' as currently practiced really free? If not, what difference can trade law make in addressing economically oppressive practices that nationalistic trade policies cannot? In this book Garcia offers an examination of trade law's roots in consensual exchange, highlighting the central role of consent in differentiating trade from legally facilitated coercion, exploitation or predation. The book revisits the premise of consensual exchange which underlies the rhetoric of 'free trade', and then examines the social and political conditions that are a necessary part of a more genuine trade law system, in service of the idea that recovering consent in trade law can promote human flourishing on a global scale.

Jackson: Virtuous Accomplices in International Criminal Law

Miles Jackson (Univ. of Oxford - Law) has posted Virtuous Accomplices in International Criminal Law. Here's the abstract:
Humanitarian actors sometimes have to decide whether to render assistance in situations that put them at risk of liability for aiding and abetting under international criminal law. This is the problem of the virtuous accomplice – the idea that knowingly contributing to the wrongdoing of others might, exceptionally, be the right thing to do. This article explains why the problem arises and clarifies its scope, before turning to criminal law in England and Wales and Germany to assess potential solutions. It argues that the best approach is to accept a defence of necessity – of justified complicity – and shows that such an argument works in international criminal law.

Blum: The Paradox of Power: The Changing Norms of the Modern Battlefield

Gabriella Blum (Harvard Univ. - Law) has posted The Paradox of Power: The Changing Norms of the Modern Battlefield (Houston Law Review, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:

We live in a paradox of power: our capabilities of inflicting destruction through military means are unparalleled in human history; yet, for liberal democracies, contemporary military practices are the most restrained they have ever been, at least as far as effects of military operations on civilians go.

This article describes the ways in which laws, norms, and technology have come together to produce the paradox of power. It begins with the observation that the international laws that govern resort to force by states (the jus ad bellum) have had only limited effect on states’ initiation or continuation of war, including by liberal democracies. Yet, the international laws that govern the conduct of war (the jus in bello), in combination with prevailing norms and advanced technology, have had substantial effects on how liberal democracies fight their wars. The combination of ongoing, open-ended wars that are harder to fight while complying with contemporary norms of warfare produce a set of unique challenges for liberal democracies.

The article consider possible trends that might change the paradox of power, as well as the longer-term implications of the current state of affairs. Ultimately, the article reiterates the importance of asking questions about why we go to war, of restoring jus ad bellum question, even if we have been able to make significant progress on the jus in bello.

Call for Papers: Il diritto dei trattati a 50 anni dall’adozione della Convenzione di Vienna

A call for papers has been issued for the XVI Incontro di studio fra i giovani cultori delle materie internazionalistiche, which will be held at the Università degli Studi di Trieste, on September 30-October 1, 2019. The theme is: "Il diritto dei trattati a 50 anni dall’adozione della Convenzione di Vienna." The call is here.

Thursday, May 30, 2019

Conference: International Law in Times of Trade Wars and Global Environmental Problems: Protection or Protectionism?

On May 31-June 1, 2019, the National Research University Higher School of Economics, gLAWcal – Global Law Initiatives for Sustainable Development, the ESIL Interest Group on International Environmental Law, and the ASIL Interest Group on Intellectual Property Law will hold a conference on "International Law in Times of Trade Wars and Global Environmental Problems: Protection or Protectionism?," in Moscow. The program is here.

Call for Papers: The Protection of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in the 'Age of Exits': Challenges and Perspectives

The Constitutional Court of the Indonesia, in collaboration with The Hague University of Applied Sciences, have issued a call for papers for a conference on "The Protection of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in the 'Age of Exits': Challenges and Perspectives," to be held November 21-22, 2019, in The Hague. The call is here.

New Issue: Humanity

The latest issue of Humanity (Vol. 10, no. 1, Spring 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • Benjamin Thomas White, A Grudging Rescue: France, the Armenians of Cilicia, and the History of Humanitarian Evacuations
  • Jo Guldi, World Neoliberalism as Rebellion From Below?: British Squatters and the Global Interpretation of Poverty, 1946–1974
  • Jason Zhu, Chinese Humanism: From Revolution to Redemption
  • Amy Kapczynski, The Right to Medicines in an Age of Neoliberalism
  • Erica Bornstein, The Report: A Strategy and Nonprofit Public Good
  • Nicholas Mulder, The Rise and Fall of Euro-American Inter-State War

Conference: G2 Annual Conference on WTO and Global Economic Regulation

On June 7-8, 2019, the G2 Annual Conference on WTO and Global Economic Regulation will be held in Geneva. The program is here.