In the field of EU external relations law, judicial deference has been discussed mostly within the context of the political question doctrine debate. The latter has a long pedigree in US law. Its nature, scope and legitimacy as well as its applicability in the EU external relations context are controversial and the topic has been mainly discussed in the context of the CFSP. At the same time, the CJEU’s deference to the political institutions on questions relating to international law and international relations has been overlooked in the relevant literature, despite the historic relationship between the political question doctrine and international law and the fact that, there is relevant CJEU practice.
Questions of judicial deference in the realm of foreign affairs bring to the fore fundamental constitutional questions regarding the role of the judiciary and the proper division of powers between courts and the political branches.
In this light, the contribution focuses on the question of whether and under what circumstances the EU courts follow the lead of the political branches when faced with questions of international law. By doing so, the paper purports to feed into the broader debate on deference to the political institutions in EU external relations law as well as to illuminate the constitutional dimension of the discussion.
Friday, February 6, 2026
Kassoti: International Law as a Political Question: The CJEU’s Deference to the Institutions on Questions of International Law
Thursday, February 5, 2026
Call for Papers: The European Union as a sanctioning actor: Legal and institutional developments
Saturday, November 15, 2025
Kassoti, Cabrita, & Idriz: The European Union and Regionalism: Conceptual and Contextual Perspectives
While the EU is the most emblematic Regional International Organization (RIO), the 'regional' perspective is largely absent in debates about the EU's identity and external posture. What does the 'regional' lens offer to the study of EU law? How is the regional dimension reflected in EU policymaking, and how does it impact norm production? This book offers the first critical, legal account of the EU as a RIO. It brings together scholars from different disciplines to reflect on the construction, use and misuse of the 'region' in EU law and practice and to examine how this dimension interacts with other RIOs.
Friday, October 24, 2025
Call for Papers: The Rule of Law and the External Action of the European Union
Thursday, August 21, 2025
Marceddu: EU Values in Investment Law and Policy: Promises of Democracy and Rule of Law?
Is it possible that the EU premises of democracy and rule of law transform the global landscape of international investments? For realists, this is a calculated political move- an opportunity for the EU to shape the world according to the rules established in Brussels. To the most skeptical, the ambition to export these values might seem too grandiose, if not far-fetched, especially considering that the system somewhat displays these features already. Yet the more idealistic, like the author of this book, would find it fascinating, especially given the undeniable visionary component that has permeated the EU story since its beginning.
EU Values in Investment Law and Policy intends to carry this fire and continues to tell precisely that story of vision, ambition, and influence. Inspired by premises that have aspired to become promises of democracy and rule of law, the book critically examines how- and how far- these EU values extended their reach into international investment law and policy. While the book is not an ode to the EU, there is plenty that is admirable in the EU transmission efforts and is likely to leave an imprint on the investment regime's dynamics. It is these efforts that this book unravels to explain how the international investment system deficits are turned into an opportunity for normative change.
The book seeks to establish a solid analytical foundation to unpack the EU's evolving aspirations as a global leader in reimagining traditional investment rules. Through a careful critique of EU initiatives, it sheds light on the fine line between innovation and dogmatism, showing where the EU has genuinely (re)shaped and advanced international norms and where its bold rhetoric meets its limits.
For scholars, practitioners, and those intrigued by the intersection of law, policy, and global governance, EU Values in Investment Law and Policy offers a captivating exploration of how a visionary Europe continues to inspire change in international investment, setting the stage for a fairer and more value-driven global system.
Monday, March 31, 2025
Seminar: The European Union and international law in times of Trump II
Sunday, March 23, 2025
Workshop: EU Accession to the ECHR: Procedural Hurdles and Prospects Before the ECtHR
Wednesday, December 18, 2024
De Coninck: The EU’s Human Rights Responsibility Gap: Deconstructing Human Rights Impunity of International Organisations
Can the EU be held legally responsible for its contributions to human rights harms in its Integrated Border Management policy? Or do systemic legal design flaws in the EU's human rights responsibility regime give rise to a significant responsibility gap?
This book delves into these pressing questions, offering a transversal analysis of applicable legal frameworks under international and EU law. Divided into three parts, the book first analyses the international and EU human rights responsibility frameworks, revealing both 'normative incongruency' as well as 'liability incongruency'. Part two applies these frameworks to specific illustrations within the four tiers of the EU's Integrated Border Management, exposing the critical points where responsibility falters. Building on these findings and drawing from shared responsibility and relationality theories, part three briefly introduces 'Relational Human Rights Responsibility' as an alternative method to ascertaining human rights responsibility of the EU specifically, and international organisations more generally.
Saturday, September 21, 2024
AJIL Unbound Symposium: Next Generation EU, Crisis Budgeting, and the Empowerment of Supranational Institutions
Sunday, May 5, 2024
Call for Papers: Between crisification and legal resilience: Change and stability in EU external relations law
Saturday, March 30, 2024
Kulick: Constitutional Review of Investment Treaties by the European Court of Justice
The review of investment treaties by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) tells a story of inconsistency. As is well known, the Court rejected investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) in the form of ad hoc arbitration in Achmea and Komstroy – and accepted it in the Investment Court System (‘ICS’) variety of the Canada-EU Free Trade Agreement (‘CETA’) in its Opinion 1/17. Taking a closer look at the various lines and subplots of this story, however, reveals three common themes. First, the CJEU’s review of investment treaties is a constitutional review not only in name but also in substance. It charges the law of internal and external EU commercial relations with the ‘values’ of Art. 2 TEU and thus introduces a ‘thick constitutionalism’ to this otherwise seemingly unspectacular area of EU policy: The Court does not merely insist on a review that may be characterized as constitutional in form – based on normative hierarchy and setting a floor and a ceiling to what is compatible with EU law. It also insists that it is tasked to protect the ‘values’ of the Union and makes them doctrinally operational by way of its – self-styled – role as exclusive guardian of the EU legal system. Second, such ‘thick constitutionalism’ provides an explanation for the doctrinal inconsistency in the Court’s jurisprudence. Promoting the ‘values’ of Art. 2 TEU in EU external relations requires a strategy of Voice, rather than Exit – and Opinion 1/17 enables the Commission and the Member States (in mixed agreements) to exercise such voice. Third, the impact of such ‘thick constitutionalism’ and the CJEU’s intention to provide the EU with Voice in its external economic relations vis-à-vis ISDS has repercussions regarding the Union’s agenda and wriggle-room in the current debates on ISDS reform in UNCITRAL Working Group III and in its current and future treaty practice.
Part II briefly recounts the main plot of this story, marking three milestones in the development of the CJEU’s case law thus far. In Part III, I will analyse and assess the Court’s jurisprudence with respect to the constitutional stakes it raises (III.1.) and regarding the different strategy it employs in order to ‘integrate’ the Union’s values also into its external commercial relations (III.2.). Part IV discusses how the Court’s ‘thick constitutionalism’ may impact the future of ISDS, both regarding the institutional and procedural matters as well as with respect to the substance of international investment agreements (‘IIAs’). Part V concludes.
Wednesday, September 27, 2023
Conference: Western Sahara in the International Legal Order
Saturday, August 5, 2023
Damjanovic: The European Union and International Investment Law Reform: Between Aspirations and Reality
In order to understand the reform of international investment law envisioned by the EU, the author provides a comprehensive but concise analysis of the EU reform approaches, its constitutional and legal framework, the concepts of the rule of law and legitimacy, and the reasons for the reform. In particular, the book exposes tensions between the EU aspiration to enhance the rule of law in international investment law, as a means of legitimising this legal discipline, and the challenges of its reform approaches in practice. The analysis combines substantive and procedural aspects of the EU reform of international investment law in the intra-EU context and EU external relations. This book thus critically evaluates the EU vision of the rule of law in international law and its contribution to the development of international law in the field of investment.
Sunday, June 25, 2023
Call for Papers: Western Sahara
Tuesday, June 6, 2023
Conference: EU Accession to the ECHR: “If at first you don’t succeed . . .”
Thursday, May 18, 2023
Montanaro: The European Union and International Investment Law: The Two Dimensions of an Uneasy Relationship
This book explores the interaction between the EU and international investment law, both at the internal level, namely within the EU internal market, and at the external level, i.e. in the context of its relations with third States.
The joint treatment of these dimensions reveals that the EU has assumed an ostensibly ambivalent attitude towards international investment law. At the internal level, it has consistently asserted that intra-EU international investment agreements (IIAs) are not compatible with EU law and advocated their termination. At the external level, by contrast, it has eagerly deployed IIAs to develop its post-Lisbon international investment policy.
The book finds that beneath this apparent ambivalence towards international investment law ultimately lies the EU's attempt to impose, both internally and externally, its own original model of regulation of cross-border investment. It then argues that the EU adopted this approach with a view to supporting its internal market, enhancing its external influence, and, ultimately, pursuing long-term 'federal aspirations'. Finally, the book identifies the legal and political obstacles that have curtailed the EU's efforts at both the internal and the external level.





