Wednesday, March 18, 2009

New Issue: International Legal Materials

The latest issue of International Legal Materials (Vol. 47, no. 5, September 2008) is out. Contents include:
  • United States Supreme Court: Boumediene v. Bush, with introductory note by Julian Davis Mortenson
  • United States Supreme Court: Munaf v. Geren, with introductory note by Stephen I. Vladeck
  • International Court of Justice: Request for Interpretation of the Judgment in Case Concerning Avena and other Mexican Nationals, with introductory note by Chiara Giorgetti
  • International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda: Prosecutor v. Kanyarukiga—Decision on Prosecutor’s Request for Referral to the Republic of Rwanda, with introductory note by Ruth Frölich
  • Supreme Court of Israel: Anonymous v. Israel, with introductory note by Scott Lyons
  • United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit: Gandara v. Bennett, with introductory note by Ronald J. Bettauer
  • United Nations Security Council Resolution 1822, with introductory note by David P. Stewart
  • United Nations Security Council Resolution 1820, with introductory note by Marianne Mollmann
  • International Criminal Court: Summary of the Prosecutor’s Application for Warrant of Arrest Against Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir, with introductory note by William Slomanson
  • International Court of Justice: Sovereignty over Pedra Branca/Pulau Batu Puteh, Middle Rocks and South Ledge (Malaysia/Singapore), with introductory note by David A. Colson and Brian J. Vohrer

New Issue: Cuadernos de Derecho Transnacional

The inaugural issue of Cuadernos de Derecho Transnacional (Vol. 1, no. 1, March 2009) is out. Contents include:
  • Tito Ballarino, Il Regolamento Roma I: forza di legge, effetti, contenuto
  • Hilda Aguilar Grieder, Los contratos internacionales de distribución comercial en el Reglamento Roma I
  • Alfonso-Luis Calvo Caravaca & Javier Carrascosa Gonzalez, La Ley aplicable al divorcio en Europa: el futuro Reglamento Roma III
  • Maria del Pilar Diago Diago, El comercio internacional de diamantes: sistema de certificación del Proceso Kimberley
  • Pietro Franzina, Las relaciones entre el Reglamento Roma I y los convenios internacionales sobre conflictos de leyes en materia contractual
  • Antonio Leandro, La legge applicabile alla revocatoria fallimentare nel Regolamento (CE) nº 1346/2000
  • Andrés Rodriguez Benot, La exclusión de las obligaciones derivadas del Derecho de familia y sucesiones del ámbito material de aplicación del Reglamento Roma I
  • Francisco Martinez Rivas, Traslado internacional de sede social en la Unión Europea: del caso Daily Mail al caso Cartesio. Veinte años no son nada
  • Maria Dolores Ortiz Vidal, El caso Grunkin-Paul: notas a la STJUE de 14 de octubre de 2008

New Issue: Journal of Conflict Resolution

The latest issue of the Journal of Conflict Resolution (Vol. 53, no. 2, April 2009) is out. Contents include:
  • Erik Gartzke & Matthew Kroenig, A Strategic Approach to Nuclear Proliferation
  • Matthew Kroenig, Importing the Bomb: Sensitive Nuclear Assistance and Nuclear Proliferation
  • Matthew Fuhrmann, Taking a Walk on the Supply Side: The Determinants of Civilian Nuclear Cooperation
  • Erik Gartzke & Dong-Joon Jo, Bargaining, Nuclear Proliferation, and Interstate Disputes
  • Michael Horowitz, The Spread of Nuclear Weapons and International Conflict: Does Experience Matter?
  • Robert Rauchhaus, Evaluating the Nuclear Peace Hypothesis: A Quantitative Approach
  • Kyle Beardsley & Victor Asal, Winning with the Bomb
  • Alexander H. Montgomery & Scott D. Sagan, The Perils of Predicting Proliferation

Workshops: Dörmann, O'Keefe

Knut Dörmann (International Committee of the Red Cross) will give a talk today at the University of Nottingham School of Law-International Law Association (British Branch) Regional Seminar Series on "Challenges to International Humanitarian Law in Contemporary Armed Conflicts."

Roger O'Keefe (Univ. of Cambridge - Law) will give a talk today at the International Law Association (British Branch)-University College London Faculty of Laws International Law Seminar on "Wartime Destruction and Plunder of Cultural Property: Issues of State Responsibility."

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Bradley: Foreign Officials and Sovereign Immunity in U.S. Courts

Curtis A. Bradley (Duke Univ. - Law) has posted an ASIL Insight on Foreign Officials and Sovereign Immunity in U.S. Courts.

Mistelis & Brekoulakis: Arbitrability: International and Comparative Perspectives

Loukas A. Mistelis & Stavros L. Brekoulakis have published Arbitrability: International and Comparative Perspectives (Kluwer Law International 2009). Here's the abstract:

It often seems today that no dispute is barred from resolution by arbitration. Even the fundamental question of whether a dispute falls under the exclusive jurisdiction of a judicial body may itself be arbitrable. Arbitrability is thus an elusive concept; yet a systematic study of it, as this book shows, yields innumerable guidelines and insights that are of substantial value to arbitral practice.

Although the book takes the form of a collection of essays, it is designed as a comprehensive commentary on practical issues that emerge from the idea of arbitrability. Fifteen leading academics and practitioners from Europe and the United States each explore different facets of arbitrability always with a perspective open to international developments and comparative evaluation of standards.

The presentation falls into two parts: in the first the focus is on the general features of arbitrability, its rationale and the laws applicable to it. In the second, arbitrability is specifically examined in the context of administrative, criminal, corporate, IP, financial, commercial, and criminal law

This book has its origins in an International Conference on Arbitrability held at Athens in September 2005. Seven papers presented there are here reviewed and updated, and nine others are added.

The subject of the book – arbitrability – is one that is much talked about, but seldom if ever given the in-depth treatment presented here. Arbitrators and other practitioners in the field will welcome the way the analysis moves logically from theory to practice regarding every issue, and academics will recognize a definitive treatment of arbitrability as understood and applied in the settlement of disputes today.

New Volume: Anuario Español de Derecho Internacional

The latest volume of the Anuario Español de Derecho Internacional (Vol. 24, 2008) is out. Contents include:
  • José B. Acosta Estévez, Método, técnica, sistemática y sectorialización del derecho internacional público
  • Mª Ángeles Cano Linares, El derecho internacional humanitario frente al uso de la fuerza como actividad empresarial: ¿el fin de un monopolio?
  • María José Cervell Hortal, El derecho internacional y los recursos naturales compartidos
  • Daniel Ignacio García San José, La elaboración de derecho internacional más allá del consentimiento estatal: la emergente legalidad internacional de base consensual
  • Javier A. González Vega, ¿Colmando los espacios de "no derecho" en el convenio europeo de derechos humanos?: su eficacia extraterritorial a la luz de la jurisprudencia
  • Francisco José Pascual Vives, La competencia del centro internacional para el arreglo de las diferencias relativas a inversiones (CIADI) para proteger las inversiones extranjeras realizadas por los particulares: el laudo de 8 de mayo de 2008 dictado por un tribunal del CIADI en el caso Víctor Pey Casado y Fundación Presidente Allende y la República de Chile (caso CIADI nº ARB/98/2)
  • Antonio Blanc Altemir, La V Cumbre Unión Europea-América Latina y Caribe: ¿hacia un cambio de método en las relaciones birregionales?
  • Rosana Garciandía Garmendia, La aplicación española de las normas de derecho internacional contra la corrupción
  • Javier Jordán, Las nuevas insurgencias: análisis de un fenómeno estratégico emergente
  • Pablo Zapatero Miguel, Libre comercio y sanciones multilaterales

BIICL: Investment Protection and the Rule of Law: Change or Decline?

Today, the British Institute for International and Comparative Law will host an event on "Investment Protection and the Rule of Law: Change or Decline?" Speakers include Yves Fortier and Norah Gallagher.

BIICL: Is the UN Security Council above the law?

Today, the British Institute of International and Comparative Law will host an event on "Is the UN Security Council above the law? - Insights on sanctions, terrorism, the occupation of Iraq and UN peacekeeping from the Kadi, Saramati and Al Jedda cases." Speakers include: Elizabeth Wilmshurst, Vera Gowlland-Debbas, and Nigel White.

Symposium: 15 Years After Genocide: Where Now for Rwanda?

Today, Oxford Transitional Justice Research, Oxford Institute for Ethics, Law and Armed Conflict, and European Studies at Oxford will host a symposium on "15 Years After Genocide: Where Now for Rwanda?" The program is available here.

Monday, March 16, 2009

LA Times: Judging the ICC

Today, the Los Angeles Times contains an editorial on whether the United States should ratify the Rome Statute and join the International Criminal Court. For a different view, see David Kaye's op-ed in the Times last week. Here's the editorial:

The Nuremberg trials at the close of World War II were controversial in their day. Advocates saw civilized nations imposing just retribution for acts of depravity; critics saw an exercise of victors' justice, with rules of warfare imposed after the fact. From that divisive history emerged a movement to create a permanent international court in which charges of genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity could be heard -- and a long debate over the wisdom of the idea. In the 1990s, ad hoc tribunals were created to consider the atrocities in Bosnia and Rwanda. And in 1998, after negotiations in which the Clinton administration played an influential role, the United Nations adopted the Rome Statute creating the International Criminal Court.

President Clinton was never fully satisfied with the result, waiting until the closing days of his administration to sign the treaty and declining to send it to the Senate for ratification. For his part, President Bush not only officially "unsigned" the Rome Statute in 2002 but signed laws passed by the Republican Congress intended to abolish the court -- going so far as to authorize the president to invade any country that detained an American on its behalf.

The 108 countries that have joined the court include most of the world's democracies and U.S. allies; our fellow holdouts include the likes of Russia, China, Iran, North Korea, Sudan, Cuba and Saudi Arabia. The court is currently proceeding with cases against officials from four African countries, and this month, in its first such action against a sitting head of state, it issued an arrest warrant for Sudanese President Omar Hassan Ahmed Bashir on charges of war crimes in Darfur. The warrant was heralded by President Obama, who has said that the United States should join the court.

Obama's position has reopened the debate in this country about how best to protect internationally recognized human rights across nations with varying approaches to enforcement of those rights within their borders. The discussion raises complicated questions and continues to divide people of goodwill, including the members of The Times' editorial board. Indeed, we are so evenly divided that we are departing from our practice of presenting a single, consensus view and instead offering our strongest justifications on both sides of the issue.

The case for

The arguments against joining the International Criminal Court are rooted in fear that Americans might one day face prosecution and judgment by foreigners in The Hague, and insecurity about our own legal and political systems being strong enough to prevent that from happening. But the ICC has jurisdiction only in cases in which a suspect's home government is “unwilling or unable” to investigate or try him itself. The court is designed to try genocidal dictators and war criminals from countries in which the rule of law is nonexistent or the courts are in thrall to the regime. The notion that this could apply to the United States is laughable, yet it was the basis of Bush administration objections.

More specifically, opponents of the court worry that if future American leaders pursue terrorists by bending international and constitutional law to the extent that Bush and former Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld did, they could be subject to prosecution for war crimes. Yet the Rome Statute sets a high bar for an ICC investigation of leadership crimes -- they must involve a high degree of magnitude and criminal intent, which would protect Bush and Rumsfeld from the charges leveled by all but their harshest critics.

If American leaders were guilty of atrocities, our own lawmakers and courts could be expected to properly investigate and prosecute them, rendering the ICC moot. And if the threat of an ICC investigation makes future American leaders think twice before approving extraordinary rendition of terrorist suspects or torture of prisoners -- actions that deeply compromised this nation's core principles and its moral standing in the world -- so much the better.

Court opponents also make much of the fact that suspects are tried exclusively by judges rather than juries. The reason for this is obvious -- how would the court assemble a jury of Americans to try someone in The Hague? -- and the argument that it should rule out U.S. participation is specious. The United States has long been extraditing citizens to foreign countries for nonjury trials.

There are ways to protect Americans from politicized international prosecution. David Scheffer, lead negotiator for the Clinton administration in the drafting of the Rome Statute, and former Navy Judge Advocate General John D. Hutson wrote a paper last year for the Century Foundation pointing out that many of the countries that have ratified the treaty have added "declarations" to the document. These lay out the terms under which they intend to honor the pact. Among other things, the United States could declare that a panel of legal experts from outside the government (such as retired military lawyers) would have to determine that the U.S. had been unable or unwilling to prosecute its own citizens before they could be surrendered to the court, and that the U.S. would withdraw from the treaty if it determined that ICC judges or prosecutors had become too politically biased to perform their duties fairly. No objections have ever been raised to such declarations.

And there's an added reason for the United States to join now. Countries cooperating with the ICC are considering adding a fourth "crime" to the court's mandate: aggression. The United States could wield far more influence in defining this crime, and making sure it doesn't tie future leaders' hands in the fight against terrorists, as a signatory to the treaty. Obama should sign it, whether Congress is ready to ratify it or not.

The case against

When the United States rejects isolation and exceptionalism, and embraces transnational cooperation, it generally is moving along a progressive path that over the decades has led to mutual respect in the affairs of nations, better stewardship of the planet's resources, the gradual reduction of poverty and, most important, broader recognition of individual rights. But not every international body is necessarily part of that movement.

The International Criminal Court has many of the features that suggest a place in the progressive tradition, such as cross-border cooperation and procedural safeguards. But a closer look shows that the ICC, as it is presently constituted, would undermine, not enhance, the march toward international justice. The United States should not join.

The ICC has little in common with multilateral treaty and trade organizations that govern the conduct of states and deal with goods, finance, fishing rights, carbon emissions, even deployment of military forces. The U.S. can and should countenance a gradual and case-by-case sharing of sovereignty on such issues for the broader good. But none of those organizations purport to have jurisdiction over an individual's life, limb or liberty.

Protecting the fundamental right of the criminally accused to a public trial by a jury of one's peers was a core reason for the American Revolution; it remains one of the primary purposes of our government. The Declaration of Independence cites among the reasons for rebellion against the king of Britain his assertion of power to remove citizens from their justice system and transport them out of the Colonies for trials before special courts with their own rules. That misuse of power is not simply a historical relic; it looms large today as the nation grapples with the Bush administration's attempt to arrest citizens and try them before military tribunals without public jury trials.

We recognize that a government exists at the will of and with the consent of the governed, and therefore the governed implicitly agree to be bound by its criminal laws. International organizations exist with the consent of their member states, so only those governments, and not the individuals, have submitted themselves to the collective will.

The ICC's defenders argue that, in practice, the United States could back out any time one of its citizens is threatened with prosecution. That's an untenable position twice over. First, it accepts the notion that the U.S. should join with its figurative fingers crossed behind its back. That's not multilateral cooperation; that's a farce. And second, criminal justice is meant to protect the accused, especially the unpopular one. The U.S. government must not be permitted to offload criminal defendants to an international court whenever protections such as jury trials become inconvenient.

The issue is not whether other forms of trial are legitimate; Americans are and should be subject to the criminal justice systems of whatever nation in which they are accused of crimes. The issue is whether the United States as a matter of policy should adopt, for the first time, one of those systems as party to an extra-national authority with power over anyone in the world. Our role should be to guarantee jury rights for the accused, not to give up and say that this protection is no longer fundamental because it's inconvenient in this new context.

New Volume: Baltic Yearbook of International Law

The latest volume of the Baltic Yearbook of International Law (Vol. 8, 2008) is out. Contents include:
  • Arbitration in the Baltics: Contemporary Issues
    • Galina Žukova, Arbitration in Three Baltic States: A Thorny Path of Learning
    • Jan Ramberg, What Arbitrators Can and Cannot Do
    • Asko Pohla, New Arbitration Legislation in Estonia: Role of State Courts in Arbitral Proceedings
    • Inga Kačevska, An Arbitration Agreement in Latvian Arbitration Environment
    • Kalvis Torgāns, Possible Solutions to Challenges of Arbitral Awards in Latvia
    • Rimantas Simaitis & Renata Beržanskienė, Arbitration in Lithuania: The Matter of Fact
    • Nina Vilkova, Arbitration Agreement and its Impact upon the Efficiency of Dispute Resolution in International Commercial Arbitration
    • Ieva Kalniņa, Iura Novit Curia: Scylla and Charybdis of International Arbitration?
    • Mārtiņš Paparinskis, Barcelona Traction: A Friend of Investment Protection Law
  • Jaanika Erne, Conferral of Powers by the Estonian State on International Organisations
  • Loreta Šaltinytė, Interpreting an Arbitration Clause under Lithuanian Law of 1993: Svenska Petroleum v. the Government of the Republic of Lithuania
  • Rytis Satkauskas, Lithuanian-Latvian Border Arbitration 1920–1921

Symposium: Treaties and Domestic Law After Medellín v. Texas

The latest issue of the Lewis & Clark Law Review (Vol. 13, no. 1, Spring 2009) contains a symposium on "Treaties and Domestic Law After Medellín v. Texas." Contents include:
  • Ingrid Wuerth, Medellín: The New, New Formalism?
  • Paul B. Stephan, Open Doors
  • John T. Parry, A Primer on Treaties and § 1983 after Medellín v. Texas
  • Scott W. Lyons, Breach Without Remedy in the International Forum and the Need for Self-Help: The Conundrum Resulting from the Medellín Case

New Issue: World Arbitration and Mediation Review

The latest issue of the World Arbitration and Mediation Review (Vol. 2, no. 3, 2008) is out. Contents include:
  • David D. Caron & Seth Schreiberg, Anticipating the 2009 U.S. "Fairness in Arbitration Act"
  • Charles H. Brower, II, Hall Street Assocs. v. Mattel, Inc.: Supreme Court Denies Enforcement of Agreement to Expand the Grounds for Vacatur Under the Federal Arbitration Act
  • Véronique Camerer & Christina G. Hioureas, Glamis Gold, Ltd. v. United States of America: A Case Study on Document Production and Privilege in International Arbitration
  • Ruth Teitelbaum, Towards a Presumption of Transparency in Investment Arbitration
  • Thomas W. Walsh, The UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules and First Options: Failing to Clearly and Unmistakably Evince the Intent to Arbitrate Issues of Arbitrability

Workshop: Boyle

Alan Boyle (Univ. of Edinburgh - Law) will give a talk today at the Oxford Public International Law Discussion Group on "Recent Developments in International Environmental Law: A Subject Comes of Age?"

Sunday, March 15, 2009

New Issue: European Human Rights Law Review

The latest issue of the European Human Rights Law Review (2009, no. 1) is out. Contents include:
  • Navanethem Pillay, Human Rights in United Nations Action: Norms, Institutions and Leadership
  • Michael Kirby, Legal Discrimination Against Homosexuals—A Blind Spot of the Commonwealth of Nations?
  • Susan Marks, Human Rights and the Bottom Billion
  • Tamar Feldman, Indirect Victims, Direct Injury: Recognising Relatives as Victims under the European Human Rights System
  • Andreas Dimopoulos, Intellectually Disabled Parents before the European Court of Human Rights and English Courts

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Inama: Rules of Origin in International Trade

Stefano Inama (UNCTAD) has published Rules of Origin in International Trade (Cambridge Univ. Press 2009). Here's the abstract:
This book discusses the different aspects of the rules of origin with a multidisciplinary perspective. It offers the first overview on the status of the negotiations of non-preferential rules of origin under the WTO agreement on rules of origin after more than ten years of negotiations and the possible implications for other WTO agreements. This book deals extensively with preferential rules of origin – both under unilateral trade instruments like GSP, EBA, and AGOA and in free trade areas. Inama analyzes the experience of the United States and the EU in developing the NAFTA and Pan-European rules of origin. He also compares and discusses the parallel experiences of the major southern regional trade agreements – such as Mercosur and ASEAN – and the ASEAN–China free trade area, as well as Comesa and SADC in their negotiations of the European partnership agreements (EPAs) with the EU. It discusses the evolution of the different sets of rules of origin, the technical options for drafting rules of origin, a methodology for drafting product specific rules origin, and the possible implications.

Friday, March 13, 2009

Call for Papers: International Law Weekend 2009

The American Branch of the International Law Association has issued a call for papers for its annual International Law Weekend, to take place October 22-24, 2009, at Fordham Law School in New York. Here's the call:

On October 22-24, 2009, the American Branch of the International Law Association ("ABILA") will hold its annual International Law Weekend in New York, bringing together hundreds of practitioners, members of the governmental and non-governmental sectors and students.

The conference will feature numerous panels, Ms. Lucy F. Reed, President of the American Society of International Law, as distinguished speaker, receptions, and the ABILA's annual meeting.

International Law Weekend 2009 will take place at the Association of the Bar of the City of New York on October 22, 2009, and at Fordham University School of Law on October 23rd and 24th. The Weekend's theme is "Challenges to Transnational Governance".

The economic, political, and social changes of the last decade have re-shaped international law and deeply affected its role and practice, along with the identity and attitude of its participants. This year's Weekend will address the challenges posed by these changes with an emphasis on the emergence of the notion of "transnational governance" and the issues related to it, including:

  • Re-ordering, organizing, and monitoring: Is this what trasnational governance is about?
  • Who is in charge of transnational governance?: A discussion of the (sometimes new) role of international organizations, states, NGOs, regions, companies, private individuals, and others.
  • Governing what?: The contents and scope of transnational governance
  • The impact of transnational governance on international trade, foreign investment, and dispute resolution mechanisms.
  • In the new context, what is the role of regulatory international law?

The ILW 2009 co-chairs are Pierre Bodeau-Livinec of the United Nations Office of Legal Affairs, Wil Burns, Editor in Chief, Journal of International Wildlife Law & Policy, and Aníbal M. Sabater, Partner, Fulbright & Jaworski International LLP.

Please submit panel proposals to the co-chairs by April 10, 2009.

ICJ: Dispute regarding Navigational and Related Rights (Costa Rica v. Nicaragua) (Conclusion of Public Hearings)

Yesterday, the International Court of Justice concluded its public hearings in the case concerning the Dispute regarding Navigational and Related Rights (Costa Rica v. Nicaragua). (Press release here; hearing transcripts here; written proceedings here.) The dispute concerns Nicaraguan regulation of Costa Rican use of the San Juan River, which constitutes a significant portion of the two countries' common border.

Here are the submissions of the parties:

For Costa Rica:

May it please the Court to adjudge and declare that the Republic of Nicaragua has:

(a) the obligation to allow all Costa Rican vessels and their passengers to navigate freely on the San Juan for purposes of commerce, including communication and the transportation of passengers and tourism;

(b) the obligation not to impose any charges or fees on Costa Rican vessels and their passengers for navigating on the river;

(c) the obligation not to require persons exercising the right of free navigation on the river to carry passports or obtain Nicaraguan visas;

(d) the obligation not to require Costa Rican vessels and their passengers to stop at any Nicaraguan post along the river;

(e) the obligation not to impose other impediments on the exercise of the right of free navigation, including timetables for navigation and conditions relating to flags;

(f) the obligation to allow Costa Rican vessels and their passengers while engaged in such navigation to land on any part of the bank where navigation is common without paying any charges, unless expressly agreed by both Governments;

(g) the obligation to allow Costa Rican official vessels the right to navigate the San Juan, including for the purposes of resupply and exchange of personnel of the border posts along the right bank of the river with their official equipment, including service arms and ammunition, and for the purposes of protection as established in the relevant instruments, and in particular the Second Article of the Cleveland Award;

(h) the obligation to facilitate and expedite traffic on the San Juan, within the terms of the Treaty of 15 April 1858 and its interpretation by the Cleveland Award of 1888, in accordance with Article 1 of the bilateral Agreement of 9 January 1956;

(i) the obligation to permit riparians of the Costa Rican bank to fish in the river for subsistence purposes.

Further, the Court is requested to adjudge and declare that by reason of the above violations, Nicaragua is obliged:

(a) immediately to cease all the breaches of obligations which have a continuing character;

(b) to make reparation to Costa Rica for all injuries caused to Costa Rica by the breaches of Nicaragua’s obligations referred to above, in the form of the restoration of the situation prior to the Nicaraguan breaches and compensation in an amount to be determined in a separate phase of these proceedings; and

(c) to give appropriate assurances and guarantees that it shall not repeat its unlawful conduct, in such form as the Court may order.

The Court is requested to reject Nicaragua’s request for a declaration.

For Nicaragua:

May it please the Court to adjudge and declare that:

The request of Costa Rica in her Memorial, Reply and oral pleadings are rejected in general, and in particular, on the following bases:

(a) either because there is no breach of the provisions of the Treaty of Limits of 15 April 1858 or any other international obligation of Nicaragua;

(b) or, as appropriate, because the obligation breach of which is alleged, is not an obligation under the provisions of the Treaty of Limits of 15 April 1858 or under general international law.

Moreover the Court is also requested to make a formal declaration on the issues raised by Nicaragua in Section II of the Chapter VII of her Counter-Memorial, in Section I, Chapter VI of her Rejoinder and as reiterated in these oral pleadings.

Krisch: Global Administrative Law and the Constitutional Ambition

Nico Krisch (Hertie School of Governance) has posted Global Administrative Law and the Constitutional Ambition. Here's the abstract:
The emergence of global governance has called into question many of the tools and concepts by which the traditionally dichotomous spaces of national and international politics and law were ordered, and various structuring proposals are competing to take their place. In this paper I examine two such proposals - global constitutionalism and global administrative law. Both represent distinct visions of how to approach the challenge, their key difference lying in their respective ambitions: constitutionalist visions set out to describe and develop a fully justified global order, while global administrative law is more limited in scope, focusing on particular elements of global governance and confining itself to the analysis and realisation of narrower political ideals, especially accountability. Such a limited approach raises serious problems, most prominently difficulties in separating 'administrative' from 'constitutional' issues and the risk of legitimising illegitimate institutions. But it also bears significant promise as it allows to focus on, and begin to answer, crucial questions of global governance without leaping to grand designs borrowed from dissimilar contexts and likely at odds with the fluid and diverse character of the postnational polity.

Nollkaemper: State Responsibility for International Crimes: A Review of Principles of Reparation

André Nollkaemper (Univ. of Amsterdam - Amsterdam Center for International Law) has posted State Responsibility for International Crimes: A Review of Principles of Reparation (in Essays in Honour of Professor Kalliopi Koufa, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
Most international crimes are committed with the support or under the control of collective entities, notably states. Yet, international law tends to hold only individuals, rather than states responsible for such crimes. This is well illustrated in the case of Darfur. The prosecutor of the ICC stated that 'The information gathered points to an ongoing pattern of crimes committed with the mobilization of the whole state apparatus'. Yet, in this case legal responsibility was 'only' channeled towards the president of Sudan, somehow presuming that his arrest would remove the involvement of the state apparatus. This paper reviews the various principles of reparation that allow international law to address the state for its involvement in international crimes, rather than only individuals. It also examines the role of the Security Council in this respect.

Workshops: Fox, Saidov

Gregory H. Fox (Wayne State Univ. - Law) will give a talk today at the Lauterpacht Centre for International Law's Friday Lunchtime Lecture Series on "The Obama Administration and International Law."

Djakhongir Saidov (Univ. of Birmingham - Law) will give a talk today at the University of Nottingham Seminar Series on "Damages Under the Vienna Sales Convention: Specific Problems and Broader Lessons."

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Parry: A Primer on Treaties and Section 1983 after Medellin v. Texas

John T. Parry (Lewis & Clark - Law) has posted A Primer on Treaties and Section 1983 after Medellin v. Texas (Lewis & Clark Law Review, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
This article -- part of a symposium on the Supreme Court's 2008 decision in Medellin v. Texas -- addresses the impact of that decision on the ability of plaintiffs to bring section 1983 claims against state actors for violations of treaties. Because to my knowledge there has been no comprehensive assessment of whether section 1983 applies to treaties at all, the article first considers the textual, precedential and policy-based arguments on that question. I conclude that although the question is close, section 1983 should include treaty-based claims. Turning to Medellin, the article highlights several statements in the majority opinion to the effect that treaties are not equal to federal statutes and that courts should presume that treaties do not create private rights. The article assesses the extent to which these statements will create problems for treaty claims. Notwithstanding those problems, I argue that treaties and statutes should receive similar treatment under section 1983.

Riddell & Plant: Evidence Before the International Court of Justice

Anna Riddell & Brendan Plant have published Evidence Before the International Court of Justice (British Institute of International and Comparative Law 2009). Here's the abstract:

Some recent contentious issues about the use of evidence in cases before the International Court of Justice have highlighted the importance of fact-finding and the use of evidence before this Court. This major study by the British Institute of International and Comparative Law on the issue of evidence before the International Court of Justice has examined all aspects of the Court's relationship with facts in detail, in both contentious and advisory proceedings, from the recently refined procedure for submitting late evidence, to the hearing of live witness testimony in the Peace Palace.

Considerations of flexibility and respect for the sovereignty of the State Parties before it have traditionally deterred the Court from constructing concrete rules on matters of evidence, but the increasing numbers of cases in which a thorough consideration of the facts has been essential has highlighted that some detailed procedural guidance is necessary in order to ensure a well-functioning system of adjudication. It is apparent that the Court has paid an incerasing amount of attention to its evidentiary proceedings as a result, often encountering difficulties in the inherent tensions between the common and civil law traditions and thus a divergence of opinions on the Bench.

This book examines the history and development of the treatment of evidence since the early days of the PCIJ up to the recent Nicaragua v Honduras judgment, critically analysing the Statute and Rules of the Court, dicta from judgments and separate and dissenting opinions, the newly developed Practice Directions and academic writings on the subject. It aims not only to provide an academic discussion of the subject, but also to act as a guide to practitioners appearing before the Court.

Ullrich: Das Dienstrecht der Internationalen Organisationen

Gerhard Ullrich has published Das Dienstrecht der Internationalen Organisationen: Institutionelles Völkerrecht, Recht und Praxis (Duncker & Humblot 2009). Here's the abstract:

Gerhard Ullrich liefert eine Gesamtdarstellung des Dienstrechts der Internationalen Organisationen und verdeutlicht den Prozess der Anerkennung gemeinsamer Werte sowie die Entwicklung einheitlicher Regelungsstandards.

Im ersten Teil erläutert er die Grundlagen des Dienstrechts und gibt statistische Hinweise. Ausführlich kommentiert der Autor die Privilegien und Immunitäten der Bediensteten. Das Kernstück des Buches bildet die Untersuchung der Rechtsquellen des Dienstrechts der Internationalen Organisationen. Dabei nimmt die Rechtsprechung der internationalen Verwaltungsgerichte zu den Allgemeinen Rechtsgrundsätzen einen besonders breiten Raum ein. Diese Grundsätze bilden für alle Internationalen Organisationen einen verbindlichen Wertekanon. Eine zweite Rechtsquelle stellen die Strukturen und Elemente des normierten Dienstrechts der Internationalen Organisationen dar, die praxisorientiert kommentiert werden. Eine systematisierende Zusammenfassung in Dienstrechtskreisen gliedert die Fülle des Stoffes. Abschließend behandelt der Autor das Rechtsschutzsystem für die internationalen Bediensteten und erläutert das Verfahren vor den internationalen Verwaltungsgerichten.

Es ist heute mehr denn je gerechtfertigt, von einer Einheit in der Vielfalt des Dienstrechts zu sprechen. Dieser Trend setzt sich verstärkt fort. Dabei vollzieht sich die Rechtsangleichung nicht nur horizontal durch die Rechtsprechung der internationalen Verwaltungsgerichte zu den Allgemeinen Rechtsgrundsätzen, sondern auch vertikal durch die vielfache Übernahme bereits normierten Dienstrechts durch andere Internationale Organisationen. Mit der vorliegenden Gesamtdarstellung des Dienstrechts der Internationalen Organisationen leistet Gerhard Ullrich einen rechtsdogmatischen und praxisorientierten Beitrag zu diesem Teilbereich des institutionellen Völkerrechts.