Showing posts with label State Responsibility. Show all posts
Showing posts with label State Responsibility. Show all posts

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Symposium: State Responsibility in Crisis

Völkerrechtsblog has launched a symposium on "State Responsibility in Crisis." The posts can be found here.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Webinar: Cessation, Non-Repetition, and Reparation?

On November 27, 2026, a third webinar will be held in the ESIL Conversations series “Responsibility of States and International Organisations in Times of Accountability Gaps: 25 Years of ARSIWA and 15 Years of ARIO.” The topic is: “Cessation, Non-Repetition, and Reparation?” Details are here.

Wednesday, September 23, 2026

Webinar: Attribution

On September 28, 2026, the first webinar will be held in the new ESIL Conversations series “Responsibility of States and International Organisations in Times of Accountability Gaps: 25 Years of ARSIWA and 15 Years of ARIO.” The topic is: “Attribution.” Details are here.

Monday, September 21, 2026

Panel: The Attribution of Non-State Actor Conduct During Armed Conflict

On September 29, 2026, Global Law at Reading will host a panel discussion on "Attribution of Non-State Actor Conduct During Armed Conflict," with options for both in-person and online attendance. Chaired by Marko Milanović (Univ. of Reading), the panel brings together government and military legal advisers and academics, including Paul Berman (Counsel for International Law, House of Lords, UK Parliament), Miles Jackson (Univ. of Oxford), and Jennifer Maddocks (Univ. of Reading), to examine the attribution of non-state actor conduct to states under the International Law Commission's Articles on State Responsibility, drawing on contemporary proxy relationships such as Russia's use of separatist entities in Eastern Ukraine and Iran's "Axis of Resistance." Details and registration are here.

Thursday, March 19, 2026

Workshop: State Responsibility in Crisis

On April 30-May 1, 2026, a workshop on "State Responsibility in Crisis" will take place at the University of Bristol. The program is here. The keynote, delivered by Violeta Moreno-Lax, will be streamed online (register here). The plenary panel at the end of the workshop, bringing together the expert discussants from each session, will also be streamed online (register here).

Thursday, October 16, 2025

Call for Papers: State Responsibility in Crisis

A call for papers has been issued for a workshop on "State Responsibility in Crisis," to take place April 30-May 1, 2026, at the University of Bristol. The call is here.

Sunday, September 7, 2025

Call for Papers: The Role of the Causal Inquiry in Establishing State Responsibility in International Law (Workshop)

A call for papers has been issued for a workshop on "The Role of the Causal Inquiry in Establishing State Responsibility in International Law," to take place May 28-29, 2026, at Lund University. The call is here.

Saturday, June 14, 2025

Perez-Leon-Acevedo: Rethinking Attribution Standards for State Responsibility Concerning Mass Atrocities

Juan Pablo Perez-Leon-Acevedo (Univ. of Oxford) has published Rethinking Attribution Standards for State Responsibility Concerning Mass Atrocities (San Diego International Law Journal, Vol. 26, no. 2, 2025). Here's the abstract:
Attribution of mass atrocities to states remains a central and contested issue in international law, particularly when such acts are carried out by non-state actors or through proxy forces. This Article analyzes how states may incur responsibility for mass atrocities by examining the legal standards developed in the Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (ARSIWA) and the jurisprudence of the International Court of Justice (I.C.J.). Special attention is given to developments following the adoption of ARSIWA, including the evolving relationship between Russia and the Wagner Group, to assess how legal principles apply in modern conflict settings. While the ARSIWA framework remains applicable, the nature of mass atrocities presents unique doctrinal and evidentiary challenges, particularly when foreign states exert control over militarized private actors.

Monday, January 13, 2025

Nissel: Merchants of Legalism: A History of State Responsibility (1870–1960)

Alan Tzvika Nissel
(Pepperdine Univ. - Law) has published Merchants of Legalism: A History of State Responsibility (1870–1960) (Cambridge Univ. Press 2024). Here's the abstract:
Since the United Nations finalised its Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts in 2001, most of the attention has been on the codification history of the topic. Alan Nissel widens the historic lens to include the pre-United Nations origins, offering the first extensive study on the American contribution to the modern law of state responsibility. The book examines the recurring narrative of lawyers using international law to suit the particular needs of their clients in three key contexts: the US turn to international arbitration practice in the New World, the German theorisation of public law in the setting of its national unification, and the multilateral effort to codify international law within world bodies. This expanded historical framework not only traces the pre-institutional origins of the code, but also highlights the duality of State responsibility doctrines and the political environments from which they emerged.

Wednesday, October 23, 2024

Urs: The Elusiveness of “Interdependent Obligations” and the Invocation of Responsibility for Their Breach

Priya Urs (Univ. of Oxford) has posted The Elusiveness of “Interdependent Obligations” and the Invocation of Responsibility for Their Breach (British Yearbook of International Law, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
Since the adoption in 2001 of the International Law Commission’s ‘Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts’, attention has been increasingly drawn to the enforcement by states individually of multilateral obligations. The Commission, for its part, addressed the invocation of responsibility for breaches of such obligations by distinguishing between the respective entitlements of ‘an injured State’, under article 42, and ‘a State other than injured State’, under article 48. In line with this distinction, the existing debate has focused largely on clarifying the entitlement of ‘a State other than an injured State’ to invoke responsibility for breaches of obligations owed erga omnes partes or erga omnes, in accordance with article 48. In contrast, little or no attention is paid in the discussion to ‘interdependent obligations’, which, while deemed to constitute a subset of obligations erga omnes partes, were deliberately placed by the Commission in article 42(b)(ii) as multilateral obligations whose breach was said to injure ‘all the other States to which the obligation is owed’. This article lends necessary clarity to this ‘curious category’ of obligations with a view to the distinction between article 42(b)(ii) and article 48, both of which address breaches of multilateral obligations, but which set out different routes to the invocation of responsibility.

Saturday, December 30, 2023

Branca: Responsibility regimes for international peace operations

Eleonora Branca
(Università degli Studi Roma Tre - Law) has published Responsibility regimes for international peace operations (Editoriale scientifica 2023). Here's the abstract:

The occurrence of harmful conducts in peace operations to the detriment of the local population, which in some cases amounted to serious violations of international law, have generated a growing demand for justice by aggrieved individuals. This has led to our main research question, which looks at the legal consequences under international law of harmful conduct carried out by States and international organisations in peace operations. The study submits that the variety of actors and the complex legal interplays between them calls into question a plurality of responsibility. The term ‘responsibility regimes’ is used here to refer to three concepts generally associated with the legal notion of responsibility, namely international responsibility, accountability, and liability. The research will address the three responsibility regimes in turn, and will unfold around two main issues: i) the allocation of responsibility and ii) the remedies available under the three responsibility regimes.

International responsibility can be defined as the legal relationship that arises from the breach of an international obligation, attributable to a State or to an international organisation, in the absence of circumstances precluding wrongfulness.

The concept of accountability has a twofold meaning: on the one hand, it is understood as the duty of an entity to give account of the exercise of its powers vis à vis others, as it is the case of monitoring and reporting activities of international organizations; one the other hand, accountability implyies the possibility for other actors to hold to account an entity for the exercise of its powers against certain standards, as in the case of compliance mechanisms. In peace operations, reference can be made to the UNMIK Ombudsperson, UN HRAP, EULEX HRRP or the UN Trust Fund for Victims of SEA, to cite a few.

Liability is characterised by the obligation to pay compensation for the damage caused, regardless of whether the conduct causing the harm is internationally wrongful. In peace operations, the liability regime characterises the functioning of claims systems established by States and international organizations to settle third-party claims.

This thorough examination shows how the three responsibility regimes come into question, highlight their strengths and weaknesses in responding to the individual quest for justice vis à vis wrongful acts carried out by States and international organizations in peace operations. The hypothesis is made that the responsibility gap can be progressively closed by enhancing the functioning of each responsibility regime, whereby they would mutually complement and reinforce each other to provide a credible answer to victims of wrongful act carried out by States and international organizations in peace operations.

Tuesday, December 26, 2023

Zemach: The International Norm Against Unjust Enrichment and State Enrichment Through the Harmful Conduct of Private Parties

Ariel Zemach (Ono Academic College - Law) has posted The International Norm Against Unjust Enrichment and State Enrichment Through the Harmful Conduct of Private Parties (University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law, Vol. 45, No. 1, 2023). Here's the abstract:

States are often enriched by the flow to their coffers of wealth accrued to private actors through internationally harmful conduct such as overfishing, acts causing transboundary air or marine pollution, cyber attacks, and international corruption. A portion of the wealth acquired by private actors through such conduct is often passed on to the state through its tax system. This article argues that this form of income to the state triggers the application of the international norm against unjust enrichment. Under the international law of unjust enrichment, such income could give rise to a duty of restitution owed by the enriched state to any state harmed by the conduct of the private actors.

This article argues that the purposes of the norm against unjust enrichment – promoting individual justice between parties and removing incentives for wrongful conduct – require its application in international law to the indirect enrichment of a state as a result of internationally harmful conduct by its taxpayers. Such application of the international norm against unjust enrichment is particularly important because of (a) evidentiary difficulties in the international arena, which significantly erode the efficacy of the remedial regime that is based on the rules concerning the responsibility of states for internationally wrongful conduct; (b) the unavailability in international law of a cause of action against private actors engaging in internationally harmful conduct; and (c) the limited capacity of a state harmed by the conduct to recover from such actors under its domestic legal system. The article suggests that the purview of the international norm against unjust enrichment extends to situations of an indirect link between the loss of the claimant state and the gain of the enriched state, provided that such link is sufficiently close.

Sunday, October 15, 2023

Kulick: Interpreting the Customary Rules on State Responsibility – Text, No Text, Hypertext

Andreas Kulick (Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen) has posted Interpreting the Customary Rules on State Responsibility – Text, No Text, Hypertext (in The Rules of Interpretation of Customary International Law, P Merkouris, P Pazartzis & LA Sicilianos eds., forthcoming). Here's the abstract:

Interpreting customary international law poses various challenges. First and foremost, custom itself is an unwritten source of international law, which, however, may find expression in various written texts that may serve as the interpretive material from which to glean content and meaning of an individual customary rule. The law of state responsibility is a prime example, begging the question how to deal with several interconnected ‘texts’ – the ARSIWA, the Commentary, other ILC work, individual expressions of state practice and opinio juris and the actual unwritten customary norm hovering over all of them – and what rules should guide their interpretation. In this chapter, I draw on insights from linguistic and literary studies as well as media theory to tackle custom’s complex textuality. Its lack of a fixed textual centre, the plurality of numbers and forms of relevant expressions of culture, its openness to change, etc., so I argue, very much resembles a hypertextual structure – a specific form of intertextuality, of interconnections of semiotic signs. Hypertext is the ‘text’ displayed on an electronic digital device that references it with other texts via so-called hyperlinks. Hypertext consists of various blocks of ‘texts’, i.e. signs (written text, pictures, music, tables, diagrams, animations, videos, etc.), that are linked to each other. Hypertext is variable, it is ‘de-centered’ and it is interactive, among others: all attributes that custom shares.

Viewing custom as hypertext offers several insights. Most importantly, as its textuality differs considerably from that of a treaty, this casts doubts on whether interpreting a customary norm’s text, as a rule, should follow the methodology of treaty interpretation. The latter is based on a clear-cut voluntaristic premise that is reflected in the textual structure of the interpretive materials: the treaty text is at the centre, the other relevant ‘texts’ form different layers of the periphery. A customary norm lacks such a fixed centre and hence a hierarchical structuring of its ‘texts’. Yet, custom’s variable structure also allows for the addition of focal points: texts that, although not fixed textual centres, assume heightened interpretive authority. Such special authority derives from thorough vetting processes that the genesis of these texts underwent: either by states themselves or, additionally, by expert bodies that states accept as bestowed with particular expertise and representativeness. The ILC’s work on state responsibility is a case in point.

The variety of texts that custom provides as interpretive material requires setting micro and meta rules of interpretation. Micro rules pertain to the interpretive methodology of each specific text or set of texts: Treaty texts follow the methodology set out in Art. 31-33 VCLT, domestic legislation is to be interpreted according to the domestic rules of statutory interpretation, unilateral acts follow their own methodology, etc. I develop certain guideposts for an interpretive methodology of the ILC work on state responsibility, taking into account the specific nature and interconnectedness of its various texts. Meta rules of custom interpretation consist of the factors determining focal points and the tools to weigh potentially differing interpretive outcomes of micro rule interpretation.

Saturday, February 18, 2023

Jovanovic: State Responsibility for ʻModern Slaveryʼ in Human Rights Law: A Right Not to Be Trafficked

Marija Jovanovic
(Univ. of Essex - Law) has published State Responsibility for ʻModern Slaveryʼ in Human Rights Law: A Right Not to Be Trafficked (Oxford Univ. Press 2023). Here's the abstract:

What is ‘modern slavery’ and who is responsible for it? What is the relevance of human rights law, which primarily regulates state conduct, for practices predominantly committed by private actors? Where can victims seek justice and redress when national authorities fail to protect them? These questions are the core focus of this book.

Marija Jovanovich analyses the role and responsibility of states for addressing ‘modern slavery’ – a diverse set of practices usually perpetrated by non-state actors – against the backdrop of international human rights law. It explores the dynamic between criminal law and human rights law and reveals the different ways these legal domains work to secure justice for victims. The book considers the ‘absolute’ nature of the prohibition of modern slavery in human rights law, the range of practices covered by this umbrella term and their mutual relationships, the positive obligations of states established by international human rights tribunals owed to individuals subject to modern slavery, and the standards for assessing state responsibility in these situations. By engaging with the concept of exploitation in human rights law, Jovanovich glues together diverse practices of modern slavery, including servitude, forced labour, and human trafficking, into a coherent concept. The book elucidates the theoretical foundations of this fundamental human right and explains why human trafficking has an independent place within it. In addition to providing a comprehensive critique of the existing human rights jurisprudence, this book offers a roadmap for the future development of law on this subject emphasizing the limits of human rights law as a tool for addressing modern slavery.

Saturday, October 29, 2022

Mackenzie-Gray Scott: State Responsibility for Non-State Actors: Past, Present and Prospects for the Future

Richard Mackenzie-Gray Scott
(Univ. of Oxford - Bonavero Institute of Human Rights) has published State Responsibility for Non-State Actors: Past, Present and Prospects for the Future (Hart Publishing 2022). Here's the abstract:
This book investigates how state responsibility can be determined for the wrongdoing of non-state actors. Every day, people, businesses and societies around the world pay a price arising from interactions between states and non-state actors. From insurrections that attempt to create new governments, to states arming belligerent proxies operating overseas, to companies damaging natural environments or providing suspect services, the impact of such situations are felt in numerous ways. They also raise many questions relating to responsibility. In answering these, State Responsibility for Non-State Actors provides a picture of what the law governing this area is, what it could be, and what it should be in light of past histories, present realities and future prospects.

Friday, October 21, 2022

Orakhelashvili: Causation in International Law

Alexander Orakhelashvili
(Univ. of Birmingham - Law) has published Causation in International Law (Edward Elgar Publishing 2022). Here's the abstract:

In this cutting-edge book, Alexander Orakhelashvili addresses the doctrine of causation, examining its suitability to influence, or contribute to, the process of responsibility of State and non-State actors in international law. In doing so, the book considers the record so far and places the international legal system’s practical experience within its normative context.

Split into four chapters, the book begins by examining the workings of causation across various national legal systems, including the common law and the civil law systems. The central second chapter considers the doctrine of causation within the structure of the law of State responsibility for internationally wrongful acts, focusing mainly on the ways in which causation is both adopted and bounded within the international legal system. The next chapter deals with the practice of international courts and tribunals relating to causation, including the International Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights, and the final chapter offers some critique of secondary literature on causation and related issues arising in national and international law.

Thursday, September 29, 2022

Mackenzie-Gray Scott: State Responsibility for Non-State Actors: Past, Present and Prospects for the Future

Richard Mackenzie-Gray Scott
(Univ. of Oxford) has published State Responsibility for Non-State Actors: Past, Present and Prospects for the Future (Hart Publishing 2022). Here's the abstract:
This book investigates how state responsibility can be determined for the wrongdoing of non-state actors. Every day, people, businesses and societies around the world pay a price arising from interactions between states and non-state actors. From insurrections that attempt to create new governments, to states arming belligerent proxies operating overseas, to companies damaging natural environments or providing suspect services, the impact of such situations are felt in numerous ways. They also raise many questions relating to responsibility. In answering these, State Responsibility for Non-State Actors provides a picture of what the law governing this area is, what it could be, and what it should be in light of past histories, present realities and future prospects.

Wednesday, September 7, 2022

Besson: Theories of International Responsibility Law

Samantha Besson
(Collège de France) has published Theories of International Responsibility Law (Cambridge Univ. Press 2022). The table of contents is here. Here's the abstract:
There is no issue more central to a legal order than responsibility, and yet the dearth of contemporary theorizing on international responsibility law is worrying for the state of international law. The volume brings philosophers of the law of responsibility into dialogue with international responsibility law specialists. Its tripartite structure corresponds to the three main theoretical challenges in the contemporary practice of international responsibility law: the public and private nature of the international responsibility of public institutions; its collective and individual dimensions; and the place of fault therein. In each part, two international lawyers and two philosophers of responsibility law address the most pressing questions in the theory of international responsibility law. The volume closes with a comparative 'world tour' of the responsibility of public institutions in four different legal cultures and regions, identifying stepping-stones and stumbling blocks on the path towards a common law of international responsibility.

Sunday, July 10, 2022

Nedeski: Shared Obligations in International Law

Nataša Nedeski
(Univ. of Amsterdam - Law) has published Shared Obligations in International Law (Cambridge Univ. Press 2022). Here's the abstract:
There are various situations in which multiple states or international organizations are bound to an international obligation in the context of cooperative activities and the pursuit of common goals. This practical phenomenon of sharing international obligations raises questions regarding the performance of obligations (who is bound to do what) and international responsibility in case of a breach (who can be held responsible for what). This book puts forward a concept of shared obligations that captures this practical phenomenon and enables scholars and practitioners to tackle these questions. In doing so, it engages in positive law-based categorization and systematization, building on existing categorizations of obligations and putting forward new typologies of shared obligations. Ultimately, it is contended that the sharing of obligations has relevant legal implications: it can influence the content and performance of obligations as well as the responsibility relations that arise in case of a breach.

Monday, January 24, 2022

d'Aspremont: Time Travel in the Law of International Responsibility

Jean d'Aspremont (Sciences Po - Law; Univ. of Manchester - Law) has posted Time Travel in the Law of International Responsibility (in Theories of International Responsibility Law, Samantha Besson ed., forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
This paper grapples with the temporality which international law produces and puts the emphasis on the role which the doctrine of international responsibility plays therein. This paper particularly argues that the doctrine of international responsibility, while preserving the seriality and linearity of the temporality of international law, suspends the latter’s one-directionality by allowing anyone invoking or mobilizing the doctrine of international responsibility to travel back and forth between the past of the wrongfulness and the present of responsibility. According to this argument, international responsibility thus enables a two-directional temporality. This paper shows that such two-directional temporality constitutes a discursive device at the service of the narrative function of international responsibility.