Thursday, March 4, 2010

Lecture: Simmons on "Mobilizing for Human Rights"

Beth Simmons (Harvard Univ. - Government) will deliver a lecture today at the Duke University School of Law Center for International and Comparative Law on "Mobilizing for Human Rights."

Workshop: Lang

Andrew Lang (LSE - Law) will give a talk today at the Sydney Law School Lunchtime Seminar Series on "The Neoliberal Moment in International Law."

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Naqvi: Impediments to Exercising Jurisdiction over International Crimes

Yasmin Q. Naqvi has published Impediments to Exercising Jurisdiction over International Crimes (T.M.C. Asser Press 2010). Here's the abstract:
The assumption is growing that legal impediments to the exercise of jurisdiction are invalid in the face of the imperative to prosecute international crimes. This analysis of seven principal impediments comparatively analyses each from the perspective of their historical origins, the policy contexts justifying them and the legal arguments used by courts and commentators to either uphold the barrier to prosecution or to reject its application so that prosecution remains unhindered. The seven impediments are: (1) Amnesties, (2) Pardons, (3) Statutes of Limitation, (4) Abuse of Process, (5) Immunities, (6) Ne bis in idem (double jeopardy), and (7) Male captus bene detentus (wrongly captured, properly detained). Each chapter contains a theoretical evaluation of each impediment, as well as a discussion of relevant case-law from world-wide domestic and international jurisdictions.

Call for Papers: Energy Security and Its Impacts on the International Legal System

The British Institute of International and Comparative Law has issued a call for papers for new scholars for its annual conference, to be held June 11, 2010, in London. The conference theme is: "Energy Security and Its Impacts on the International Legal System." Here's the call:

British Institute of International and Comparative Law

Annual Conference 2010

Energy Security and its Impacts on the International Legal System

CALL FOR PAPERS

The 2010 Annual Conference of the British Institute of International and Comparative Law will be held on Friday 11 June 2009 in London. The theme of the conference will be: ‘Energy Security and Its Impacts on The International Legal System’.

This Call for Papers is for new scholars to submit a proposal for a paper to be delivered at the Conference. It is designed to encourage new academics, doctoral and masters students, and new legal professionals. A list of panels and a brief summary of the issues to be addressed by them is set out below, though this is not the final programme. Papers on national and comparative approaches to energy security or on subjects within these themes, or more generally on the topic of energy security and international law are sought.

Interested persons should submit a synopsis (350-600 words) of their proposed presentation no later than Wednesday 24 March 2009 at 5.00 pm GMT. The synopsis should provide an outline of the proposed paper and should identify the argument to be advanced, and the major issues to be addressed. Proposal submissions should be accompanied by a short CV (no more than 2 pages). The submission should indicate the author’s name, institutional affiliation and contact details.

All papers should be sent in the first instance by email to Ms Orsolya Deák at o.deak@biicl.org. The proposals will then be considered by members of the Conference Steering Group. The outcome of the review will be announced in early April 2010. Unfortunately, the British Institute of International and Comparative Law will not be able to cover travel expenses for successful applicants.

Conference Panels:

Protecting Energy Investments in a Changing Legal Regime

The regime governing investment in the energy sector is undergoing great change. There are impacts on energy investments in many ways; their structure, the obligations on the investors including environmental and possibly returns. This panel will discuss these changes as well as consider the withdrawal of Russia from the Energy Charter Process in October 2009.

Energy Security: Territorial Limits and Nuclear Power

The desire by states for energy security has transboundary consequences. This includes negotiations over use of and access to resources and territorial boundaries. The use of some energy sources can have potential impacts internationally, especially the gaining and use of nuclear power. This panel will discuss these and related issues of public international law.

Energy, Human Rights and Indigenous Peoples

The nature of many of the activities associated with energy production, such as its exploration, facilities, transport, waste products and general development, can have impacts on those living nearby. In many instances, these are indigenous peoples, with cultures and practices that may operate in a fragile environment. This panel will explore some of the relevant issues in this area, including the responses of those involved in the energy sectors to human rights and sustainable development concerns.

Energy Production, Transport and Supply: Cross Border Private Law Issues

In the chain from production to supply of energy, multiple private law issues arise concerning contracting, joint activities, ownership of pipelines, transport fee claims, changes of supplier or adjustment clauses in contracts of supply. Several of these questions can have cross-border dimensions. This panel will shed light on how the various actors in the energy sector, including consumers, can avoid the pitfalls of private law in an international context.

Competition Law and Access and Security of Energy

The energy sector has undergone detailed scrutiny by competition authorities throughout Europe, with dawn raids, sector enquiries and threats of further regulation or market investigations. This panel will consider questions such as: How has the sector coped with these various demands?; How do regulators and counsel respond, whether through innovative access remedies in merger and other cases, detailed compliance programmes, environmental initiatives and the over-riding concern to ensure security of supply and fair pricing to all?; and how will possible changes to the regulatory regime itself affect competition, regulation and the constant need for innovation?

Stahn & van den Herik: Future Perspectives on International Criminal Justice

Carsten Stahn (Leiden Univ. - Law) & Larissa van den Herik (Leiden Univ. - Law) have published Future Perspectives on International Criminal Justice (T.M.C. Asser Press 2010). Contents include:
  • Gerry Simpson, 'Satires of circumstance': some notes on war crimes trials and irony
  • Alette Smeulers & Wouter Werner, The banality of evil on trial
  • Harmen van der Wilt, Why international criminal lawyers should read Mirjan Damaška
  • Tamás Hoffmann, The gentle humanizer of humanitarian law - Antonio Cassese and the creation of the customary law of non-international armed conflict
  • Christoph Burchard, The international criminal legal process: towards a realistic model of international criminal law in action
  • Darryl Robinson, The two liberalisms of international criminal law
  • Kai Ambos, International criminal law at the crossroads: from ad hoc imposition to a treaty-based universal system
  • Frédéric Mégret, In search of the 'vertical': towards an institutional theory of international criminal justice's core
  • Kevin Jon Heller, Situational gravity under the Rome Statute
  • Mark Osiel, When law 'expresses' more than it cares to admit: comments on Heller
  • Dawn Sedman, Should the prosecution of ordinary crimes in domestic jurisdictions satisfy the complementarity principle?
  • Marta Valiñas, Interpreting complementarity and interests of justice in the presence of restorative-based alternative forms of justice
  • Elizabeth Santalla, Universal jurisdiction and the prosecution of excluded asylum seekers
  • Scott Doucet, The Inter-American Court of Human Rights and the aggravated state responsibility operationalizing the concept of state crime
  • Larissa van den Herik, Corporations as future subjects of the International Criminal Court: an exploration of the counterarguments and consequences
  • Dan Kuwali, Gray war zone? The question of contractual control of the privatization of warfare and the civilianization of the military
  • Materneau Crispin, Holding private military companies accountable for their crimes: the applicability of the commander/superior responsibility doctrine
  • Astrid Reisinger, Defining the crime of aggression
  • Nicolaos Strapatsas, Complementarity and aggression: a ticking time bomb?
  • Michael E. Kurth, The recruitment and use of child soldiers: some reflections on the prosecution of a new war crime
  • Gideon Boas, The difficulty with individual criminal responsibility in international criminal law
  • Héctor Olásolo, Current trends on modes of liability for genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes
  • Athanasios Chouliaras, From 'conspiracy' to 'joint criminal enterprise': in search of the organizational parameter
  • Göran Sluiter, Trends in the development of a unified law of international criminal procedure
  • Alexander Zahar, Witness memory and the manufacture of evidence at the international criminal tribunals
  • Liesbeth Zegveld, Remedies for war victims
  • Nino Tsereteli, Victim participation in ICC proceedings
  • Carsten Stahn, Arrest and surrender under the ICC Statute: a contextual reading

Stewart: Supreme Court Preview: The Samantar Case and the Immunity of Foreign Government Officials

David P. Stewart (Georgetown Univ. - Law) has posted an ASIL Insight on Supreme Court Preview: The Samantar Case and the Immunity of Foreign Government Officials.

Workshops: Kreß, Sivakumaran, Weiler

Claus Kreß (Univ. of Cologne - Law) will give a talk today at the University of Nottingham School of Law-International Law Association (British Branch) Regional Seminar on "Time of Decision: Some Thoughts on the Immediate Future of the Crime of Aggression."

Sandy Sivakumaran (Univ. of Nottingham - Law) will give a talk today at the UCL Faculty of Laws and International Law Association (British Branch) International Law Seminar on "Sources of Law, Non-State Armed Groups, and Internal Armed Conflict."

Joseph Weiler (New York Univ. - Law) will give a talk today at the New York University School of Law Institute for International Law and Justice International Legal Theory Colloquium on "On the Distinction between Values and Virtues in the Process of European Integration."

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Freeman: Necessary Evils: Amnesties and the Search for Justice

Mark Freeman (International Crisis Group) has published Necessary Evils: Amnesties and the Search for Justice (Cambridge Univ. Press 2010). Here's the abstract:
This book is about amnesties for grave international crimes that are adopted by states in moments of transition or social unrest. The subject is naturally controversial, especially in the age of the International Criminal Court. The goal of this book is to reframe and revitalize the global debate on the subject, and to offer an original framework for resolving amnesty dilemmas when they arise. Most existing literature and jurisprudence on amnesties deal with only a small subset of state practice and sidestep the ambiguity of amnesty’s position under international law. This book addresses the ambiguity head on and argues that amnesties of the broadest scope are sometimes defensible when adopted as a last recourse in contexts of mass violence. Drawing on an extensive amnesty database, the book offers detailed guidance on how to ensure that amnesties extend the minimum leniency possible, while imposing the maximum accountability on the beneficiaries.

Robinson: The Mysterious Mysteriousness of Complementarity

Darryl Robinson (Queen's Univ. - Law) has posted The Mysterious Mysteriousness of Complementarity. Here's the abstract:

This article explores an unusual interpretive disconnect in the discourse on complementarity, and shows how that disconnect is obscuring the most important questions about the relationship between the International Criminal Court (ICC) and national systems.

Several Chambers of the ICC have held that, in the absence of national proceedings, a case is admissible before the ICC. Many commentators regard this position as a ‘gloss’, an ‘invented’ prong, and a departure from the Statute. Interestingly, such critiques are rooted in a sincere, firmly-held and widely-shared belief that Article 17 contains a one-step test requiring either ‘unwillingness’ or ‘inability’. This article demonstrates that, contrary to the popular simplification of the complementarity test, Article 17 expressly provides not a one-step test, but a two-step test, the first explicit question of which is whether a State is investigating or prosecuting the case or has done so. Thus, admissibility-due-to-inaction is not a creative inference or an imaginative gloss; it arises from the literal, unambiguous text of Article 17.

Yet, the complementarity discourse is curiously inverted so that text is decried as 'gloss' and gloss is exalted as 'text'. The popular simplification of complementarity exercises such a powerful grip on the interpretive community that when Court applies the actual Article 17, the Court is accused of ‘departing’ from the Statute and ‘inventing’ new requirements. For some reason, the 55 words of Article 17 that explicitly require a national investigation or prosecution persistently fall into a shared blind spot. While many commentators find it a mystery that the Court believes that a case is admissible in the absence of proceedings, the real mystery is why this proposition is controversial.

Once the interpretive disconnect is exposed and misplaced recriminations about Statute violations are set aside, we discover rich ground for a much more exciting debate about the role of the Court vis-à-vis national systems. For example, how can the risk of States shirking prosecutions be managed? What are the appropriate limits on ‘burden sharing’ arrangements? Such questions are not determined by the Statute text and are as important as any questions resolved in the Rome Statute. It is hoped that this paper will help bring about and contribute to that debate.

Charlesworth & Coicaud: Fault Lines of International Legitimacy

Hilary Charlesworth (Australian National Univ. - Law) & Jean-Marc Coicaud (United Nations Univ.) have published Fault Lines of International Legitimacy (Cambridge Univ. Press 2010). Contents include:
  • Jean-Marc Coicaud, Introduction: fault lines of international legitimacy
  • Jean-Marc Coicaud, The structure of legitimacy in contemporary international politics
  • Jean-Marc Coicaud, Deconstructing international legitimacy
  • Jean-Marc Coicaud, The evolution of international order and fault lines of international legitimacy
  • Nathaniel Berman, Intervention in a 'divided world': axes of legitimacy
  • Vasuki Nesiah, From Berlin to Bonn to Baghdad: a space for infinite justice
  • Ian Johnstone, Legal deliberation and argumentation in international decision-making
  • Nishkala Suntharalingam, The United Nations Security Council, regional arrangements and peace operations
  • Dianne Otto, The Security Council's alliance of gender legitimacy: the symbolic capital of resolution 1325
  • Lorraine Elliott, Cosmopolitan militaries and cosmopolitan force
  • B. S. Chimni, Sovereignty, rights and armed intervention: a dialectical perspective
  • Ralph Wilde, Setting the terms of the debate on the legitimacy of intervention: a case study of depictions of international territorial administration missions
  • Jun Matsukuma, The legitimacy of economic sanctions: an analysis of humanitarian exemptions of sanctions and the right to minimum sustenance
  • Hilary Charlesworth, Conclusion: the legitimacies of international law

New Issue: International Journal of Refugee Law

The latest issue of the International Journal of Refugee Law (Vol. 22, no. 1, March 2010) is out. Contents include:
  • Kees Wouters & Maarten Den Heijer, The Marine I Case: a Comment
  • Kristin Bergtora Sandvik, A Legal History: the Emergence of the African Resettlement Candidate in International Refugee Management
  • Ekaterina Yahyaoui Krivenko, Muslim Women's Claims to Refugee Status Within the Context of Child Custody Upon Divorce Under Islamic Law
  • James C. Simeon, A Comparative Analysis of the Response of the UNHCR and Industrialized States to Rapidly Fluctuating Refugee Status and Asylum Applications: Lessons and Best Practices for RSD Systems Design and Administration

Waibel: Iceland's Financial Crisis - Quo Vadis International Law

Michael Waibel (Univ. of Cambridge - Law) has posted an ASIL Insight on Iceland's Financial Crisis - Quo Vadis International Law.

Workshops: Alston, Simpson

Philip G. Alston (New York Univ. - Law) will give a talk today at the Temple University School of Law International Law Colloquium on "Hobbling the Monitors: The UN Code of Conduct for Human Rights Special Procedures."

Gerry Simpson (LSE - Law) will give a talk today at the Oxford Institute for Ethics, Law and Armed Conflict on "War Crimes Trials, Solemnity and the Problem of Evil."

Monday, March 1, 2010

New Issue: Chinese Journal of International Law

The latest issue of the Chinese Journal of International Law (Vol. 9, no. 1, March 2010) is out. Contents include:
  • Agora: Military Activities in the EEZ
    • Sienho Yee, Sketching the Debate on Military Activities in the EEZ: An Editorial Comment
    • Raul (Pete) Pedrozo, Preserving Navigational Rights and Freedoms: The Right to Conduct Military Activities in China's Exclusive Economic Zone
    • Zhang Haiwen, Is It Safeguarding the Freedom of Navigation or Maritime Hegemony of the United States?—Comments on Raul (Pete) Pedrozo's Article on Military Activities in the EEZ
  • Kenneth J. Keith, International Court of Justice: Reflections on the Electoral Process
  • Bing Bing Jia, The Relations between Treaties and Custom
  • Andreas Buss, The Preah Vihear Case and Regional Customary Law
  • Comments, Essays and Notes
    • Barry Sautman, Tibet's Putative Statehood and International Law
    • Gao Jianjun, The Okinawa Trough Issue in the Continental Shelf Delimitation Disputes within the East China Sea
  • Development and History
    • The AALCO Secretariat, Report on the Forty-eighth Annual Session of the Asian-African Legal Consultative Organization
    • Wang Zonglai & Hu Bin, China's Reform and Opening-up and International Law
    • Rima Tkatova, Central Asian States and International Law: Between Post-Soviet Culture and Eurasian Civilization

New Issue: Fordham International Law Journal

The latest issue of the Fordham International Law Journal (Vol. 33, no. 1, December 2009) is out. Contents include:
  • Michal S. Gal, Antitrust in a Globalized Economy: The Unique Enforcement Challenges Faced by Small and Developing Jurisdictions
  • Chris Jenks, Notice Otherwise Given: Will in Absentia Trials at the Special Tribunal for Lebanon Violate Human Rights?
  • Jordan C. Kahn, Striking NAFTA Gold: Glamis Advances Investor-State Arbitration
  • Dimitry Kociwnov, On Options of Citizens and Moral Choices of States: Gays and European Federalism

Call for Applications: Institute for Global Law & Policy Workshop

The Institute for Global Law and Policy is accepting applications for its first annual Workshop on Global Law and Economic Policy, June 2-11, 2010 at Harvard Law School. Applications will be received until March 31, 2010. Here's the idea:

IGLP: The Workshop is an intensive ten day residential program designed for doctoral and post-doctoral scholars. The Workshop aims to promote innovative ideas and alternative approaches to issues of global law, economic policy and social justice in the aftermath of the economic crisis. The initiative will bring young scholars and faculty from around the world together with leading faculty working on issues of global law and economic policy for serious research collaboration and debate. Hosted by Harvard Law School, The Workshop aims to bring together specialists from across the arts and sciences as well as the professional schools who are interested in the intersections between law, economics and global policy.

University of Exeter School of Law and ILA (British Branch) Current Issues in International Law Seminar Series

Here's the schedule for the University of Exeter School of Law and International Law Association (British Branch) Current Issues in International Law Seminar Series:
  • March 5: Craig Barker (Univ. of Sussex), Immunities from Jurisdiction in International Law: Relic or Requirement?
  • March 12: Douglas Guilfoyle (UCL), Piracy off Somalia: The Emerging Legal Framework
  • March 15: Susan Breau (Univ. of Surrey), The Gaza Report: Implications for International Law
  • March 23: Louise Arimatsu (LSE), The Chilcot Inquiry: International Laws Post-Mortem?

Rogers: The Ethics of Advocacy

Catherine A. Rogers (Pennsylvania State Univ. - Law; Bocconi Univ. - Institute of Comparative Law) has posted The Ethics of Advocacy. Here's the abstract:
This book chapter surveys existing conflicts among national ethical rules in international arbitration, analyzes recent developments in legal ethics and proposes innovations for the international arbitration community to manage and resolve these conflicts in a manner that will both alleviate the practical problems that arise in the absence of shared ethical principles, and strengthen the system as it works to develop and enforce internally its own international legal ethics. It is one chapter in a larger volume edited by Doak Bishop, which provides analysis about the inner workings of the international arbitration system and advice for counsel operating in that system.

Conference: The Responsibility to Protect: From Principle to Practice

The European Science Foundation (ESF), in partnership with Linköping University, will host a conference on "The Responsibility to Protect: From Principle to Practice," June 8-12, 2010, in Linköping, Sweden. The preliminary program is here. Conference participation is possible only after successful application. To apply, click here. Deadline for application: March 8, 2010. Here's the idea:

Five years after its acceptance by the 2005 World Summit, it is time to consider the contribution that the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) has made and could make to the prevention of mass atrocities.

The consensus among the Member States of the United Nations, as reflected in the General Assembly debate in the summer of 2009 is broad but not necessarily deep. While there is considerable general support for R2P along the three pillars suggested by the UN Secretary-General (responsibility of states to protect their own populations, assistance and capacity building and timely responses), fundamental questions remain. For instance: what does R2P add to the already existing obligations of states and to the substantial arsenal of instruments at the possession of the international community to prevent and respond to mass atrocities? Does R2P entail a risk of opening the door to external intervention? And how can R2P be operationalised and implemented in concrete circumstances?

Knowledge of the impact of the principle is limited. Recent practice shows both instances of where the international community succeeded (Kenya) and failed (Darfur) to prevent mass atrocities, but in neither of these cases it is obvious that success or failure could be attributed directly to the use, or lack of use, of the concept of R2P.

Sunday, February 28, 2010

Symposium: International Justice in the 21st Century: The Law and Politics of the International Criminal Court

The John Marshall Law Review will host a symposium on "International Justice in the 21st Century: The Law and Politics of the International Criminal Court," April 23, 2010, in Chicago. The program is not yet available. Here's the idea:

Governed by the Rome Statute, the ICC is the first permanent, treaty based, international criminal court established to help end impunity for the perpetrators of the most serious crimes of concern to the international community. At this time, the United States is not a party to this regime. As such, the traditional role of the United States as a leader of international standards for law and justice is in peril.

This symposium will examine the impact of the ICC, the crossroads between the law and politics of international prosecutions, and re-engagement of US leadership. The symposium comes at a crucial time, as the first review conference of the ICC will be held in the summer of 2010 in Uganda, where nations of the world will gather to consider amendments to the Court's statute.

Saturday, February 27, 2010

Chaumette: Les sujets du droit international pénal

Anne-Laure Vaurs Chaumette has published Les sujets du droit international pénal: Vers une nouvelle définition de la personnalité juridique internationale? (Pedone 2009). Here's the abstract:
Cette thèse porte sur la définition de la personnalité juridique internationale. L'étude des sujets du droit international pénal est le prétexte pour vérifier la validité de la définition donnée par la Cour internationale de Justice en 1949. La Cour définissait alors le sujet de droit comme le titulaire de droits et d'obligations et de la capacité à se prévaloir de ses droits et à répondre de ses obligations. L'analyse du sujet créancier et du sujet débiteur du droit international pénal force à admettre que la définition de 1949 n'est pas appropriée pour qualifier le sujet du droit international pénal. D'une part, le sujet créancier du droit international pénal, l'Etat, se caractérise avant tout par sa capacité à déclencher le procès international pénale et non par les droits subjectifs dont il serait le titulaire. D'autre part, le sujet débiteur du droit international pénal, l'individu, se définit par sa capacité à être sanctionné par les juridictions internationales pénales et non par les obligations primaires qu'il aurait violées. Il apparaît ainsi que la personnalité juridique internationale coïncide avec la capacité à agir, que celle-ci soit active ou passive. La personnalité juridique internationale retrouve finalement sa signification étymologique : elle est le rôle de l'acteur juridique, son masque sur la scène internationale.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Pattison: Humanitarian Intervention and the Responsibility to Protect

James Pattison (Univ. of Manchester - Politics) has published Humanitarian Intervention and the Responsibility to Protect: Who Should Intervene? (Oxford Univ. Press 2010). Here's the abstract:
This book considers who should undertake humanitarian intervention in response to an ongoing or impending humanitarian crisis, such as found in Rwanda in early 1994, Kosovo in 1999, and Darfur more recently. The doctrine of the responsibility to protect asserts that when a state is failing to uphold its citizens' human rights, the international community has a responsibility to protect these citizens, including by undertaking humanitarian intervention. It is unclear, however, which particular agent should be tasked with this responsibility. Should we prefer intervention by the UN, NATO, a regional or subregional organization (such as the African Union), a state, a group of states, or someone else? This book answers this question by, first, determining which qualities of interveners are morally significant and, second, assessing the relative importance of these qualities. For instance, is it important that an intervener have a humanitarian motive? Should an intervener be welcomed by those it is trying to save? How important is it that an intervener will be effective and what does this mean in practice? The book then considers the more empirical question of whether (and to what extent) the current interveners actually possess these qualities, and therefore should intervene. For instance, how effective can we expect UN action to be in the future? Is NATO likely to use humanitarian means? Overall, it develops a particular normative conception of legitimacy for humanitarian intervention. It uses this conception of legitimacy to assess not only current interveners, but also the desirability of potential reforms to the mechanisms and agents of humanitarian intervention.

Stephan: Treaties in the Supreme Court: 1946-2000

Paul B. Stephan III (Univ. of Virginia - Law) has posted Treaties in the Supreme Court: 1946-2000. Here's the abstract:
This paper, a chapter in a forthcoming book on International Law and the Supreme Court, examines the treaty decisions of the Court during the postwar era, up until the second Bush Administration. Three patterns stand in the many (roughly 130) decisions. First, the Court acted as if the immediately preceding period – the New Deal, then the War – created a sharp break with the past, freeing the Court to address many questions as novel rather than rooted in settled practice. Second, the Court largely resisted the invocation of treaties as authority contradicting congressional statutes and executive practice regarding matters of public law, but gave greater effect to treaties that addressed what the Court perceived as matters of private interest – disputes over property ownership, contract enforcement, and liability for torts. Third, the Court did invoke treaty-based rules in cases where it perceived the desire of Congress and the President to draw on international law to fill out the meaning of particular statutes.

Noll: Sacrificial Violence and Targeting in International Humanitarian Law

Gregor Noll (Lund Univ. - Law) has posted Sacrificial Violence and Targeting in International Humanitarian Law. Here's the abstract:

International humanitarian law (IHL) does not prohibit military action resulting in the loss of civilian life at large. As long as its rules on the protection of civilians and their property are followed, the incidental causation of civilian loss is legal. Why is this so? The not-so-naïve answer is that contemporary military operations would be made difficult, if they were to be carried out under legal norms leaving no room for civilian casualties whatsoever. Such severe constraints were as undesirable for states developing ius in bello through history as the total absence of constraints. That apart, incidental and lawful civilian losses within the framework of IHL could be seen as indispensable signs in a symbolic order fettering violent conflicts in communities. With this text, I would like to outline how this possibility might be researched in a future, more comprehensive project. In choosing targeting as an area, I believe that I am close to an archetypical norm on the fettering of violence in the laws of war. The present text features two distinct steps.

First, I explore central norms on targeting in contemporary IHL, as the ultimate point of a historically grown body of thought on the lawful killing of certain civilians. This reading of the law emphasises its central ambiguities, and tries to lay bare the chains of equivalence between military objective and civilian death it constructs. A central concern is the open question of civil-political objective to be pursued through IHL-abiding war. All this will be done in the consecutive Section 2.

Second, to argue that casualties are perceived as necessary preconditions for peace in an international community, I introduce a theory explaining how the causation of incidental death of civilians, rather than the willed death of enemy combatants, plays a pacifying role in the symbolic order of international law. I wish to explore targeting norms as part of a contemporary victimisation ritual, offering the civilian casualty in exchange for divine appeasement of an international community. This approach draws on the work of René Girard explaining how communal violence is contained through ritual acts of sacrificial killings. This projection of Girardian theory on IHL norms will be performed in Section 3. A brief conclusion will be drawn in Section 4.

Call for Submissions: Space Law and International Economic Law

The Indian Journal of International Economic Law has issued a call for submissions for a special issue on "Space Law and International Economic Law." Here's the call (courtesy of Res Communis):

IJIEL is a peer-reviewed journal produced by the National Law School of India University (NLSIU), Bangalore, funded by the Indian government sponsored chair on WTO law at NLSIU. The mandate of the journal encompasses all aspects of international economic law, especially from a developing country perspective. Our Editorial Board includes renowned and respected academics such as Prof. Andrew Guzman, Ms. Jayashree Watal and Prof. Yuji Iwasawa. Prof. Jagdish Bhagwati wrote the foreword for our first issue. We have just published our second issue in October 2009.

As a young journal we try to focus on new, contemporary and interesting areas and issues. One such area is the interface between international economic law and space law, particularly topics such as the umbrella of common benefit and interest which covers international trade in space products and information, or the international financial implications of multilateral space operations.

Submissions are sought in three categories: long Articles of 10,000-12,000 words, short articles of 5,000-8,000 words and notes or comments of 2,000-4,000 words. The deadline for submissions is May 31, 2010. The issue will be published by the end of August, 2010. Citations should conform to the Bluebook system.

For further information regarding the journal, or to access the first two issues, please visit http://www.ijiel.com. Please direct queries concerning this special issue to ijiel@nls.ac.in, or directly to the Chief-Editor (Abhimanyu George Jain) at abhimanyugeorgejain@gmail.com.