Wednesday, May 22, 2019

Ingber: Congressional Administration of Foreign Affairs

Rebecca Ingber (Boston Univ. - Law) has posted Congressional Administration of Foreign Affairs (Virginia Law Review, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:

Longstanding debates over the allocation of foreign affairs power between Congress and the President have reached a stalemate. Wherever the formal line between Congress and the President’s powers is drawn, it is well established that as a functional matter, even in times of great discord between the two branches, the President wields immense power when he acts in the name of foreign policy or national security.

And yet, while scholarship focuses on the accretion of power in the presidency, presidential primacy is not the end of the story. The fact that the President usually “wins” in foreign affairs does not mean that the position the President ultimately chooses to take is preordained. In fact, questions of foreign policy and national security engage diverse components of the executive branch bureaucracy, which have overlapping jurisdictions and often conflicting biases and priorities. And yet they must arrive at one executive branch position. Thus the process of decisionmaking, the weight accorded the position of any given decisionmaker, the context in which the decision is made — together these shape the ultimate position the President takes.

This Article explores and critiques the foreign policy role Congress can — and does — play in structuring and rearranging the relative powers of those internal actors, and the processes they take to reach their decisions, in order to influence and even direct the President’s ultimate position. Having yielded much of the ground on substance, Congress has an opportunity for a second bite at the apple, and may influence the policy directions of the presidency simply by manipulating its internal workings. There are risks to deploying such “process controls,” as I term them, in lieu of direct substantive engagement, but I argue that Congress can and should use these tools more instrumentally to influence the course of foreign policy in areas where it is otherwise unlikely to assert itself as a coequal branch and necessary check on presidential power.

Hathaway: A Comparative Foreign Relations Law Agenda: Opportunities and Challenges

Oona A. Hathaway (Yale Univ. - Law) has posted A Comparative Foreign Relations Law Agenda: Opportunities and Challenges. Here's the abstract:
International law is generally understood to be made up of the rules that states accept as binding in their relations with one another. But international law is the product not only of a political and legal process that takes place between states — as this common understanding implies — but also of processes that take place within them. And yet to date there has been remarkably little cross-national work examining the role of domestic politics and law in the creation of treaties and other international law. Part of the reason for this gap is the difficulty of conducting cross-national studies of foreign relations law on a large scale. To the extent there have been comparative studies done of foreign relations law, they have been largely limited to relatively small-scale case studies. More comprehensive examination of the differences across nations in the ways in which they make international commitments is rare. This chapter aims to contribute to an emerging conversation about how best to carry out a more comprehensive examination of differences between states in the law governing their engagement in the world around them. It maps out five areas that offer opportunities and challenges for the study of comparative foreign relations law. First, the choice of methodology, whether quantitative or qualitative. Second, the under-representation of certain states in existing foreign relations scholarship. Third, the domestic political and institutional structures that shape the interplay between the legislative, executive, and judicial functions within states. Fourth, the role of geopolitics. Fifth, the chapter sounds a cautionary note about approaching international law through domestic law.

Djukić: The Right to Appeal in International Criminal Law

Drazan Djukić has published The Right to Appeal in International Criminal Law (Brill | Nijhoff 2019). Here's the abstract:
In The Right to Appeal in International Criminal Law Dražan Djukić describes appeal proceedings in international criminal law and evaluates them against human rights benchmarks. While international criminal courts and tribunals mainly comply with these benchmarks, they have fallen short in certain important areas. Despite their importance to the legal process, appeal proceedings tend to receive limited attention. On the basis of benchmarks arising from international human rights law, Dražan Djukić systematically assesses the law and practice concerning appeal proceedings in international criminal law.

New Volume: New Zealand Yearbook of International Law

The latest volume of the New Zealand Yearbook of International Law (Vol. 15, 2017) is out. Contents include:
  • Articles and Commentaries
    • Graham Hassall, Law, Culture, and Corruption in the Pacific Islands
    • S. Reindl-Krauskopf, Anti-corruption Measures from a European and Austrian Perspective: Concepts – Control – Concerns
    • Farsam Salimi, Cybercrime Threats, Offences and Special Investigation Measures from a European Perspective
    • Harmen van der Wilt, The European Arrest Warrant: A Blueprint for International Cooperation in Criminal Matters in Other Regions?
    • Liz Campbell, Brexit and the Policing of Transnational Organised Crime in Europe
    • Ray Murphy, Command Responsibility after Bemba
    • Matt Bartlett, Standard Deviation: Global Standardisation and Implications for International Law
  • The South Pacific
    • Tony Angelo, Pacific Islands Forum 2017

Trachtman: The Internet of Things Cybersecurity Challenge to Trade and Investment: Trust and Verify?

Joel P. Trachtman (Tufts Univ. - Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy) has posted The Internet of Things Cybersecurity Challenge to Trade and Investment: Trust and Verify? Here's the abstract:
This paper describes the problem of cybersecurity-based concerns regarding trade in IoT goods, and investment in manufacturing or distribution facilities for IoT goods, analyzes the applicable international law that would constrain national cybersecurity-based import or investment restrictions, and evaluates the availability of security or other exceptions to permit these defensive measures. Based on the defensive needs, and the legal constraints, it suggests some of the characteristics of a cooperative regulatory regime that can foster international trust or verification to allow trade and foreign investment in relation to IoT goods. Trade and investment in low risk consumer IoT products, such as household objects, will be manageable along traditional lines of other product standards, regulated by existing treaties such as the GATT and TBT Agreement to assure national treatment, MFN treatment, proportionality, and due respect for international standards. With respect to high risk industrial, infrastructural, medical or transportation IoT products, the path to liberal trade and investment is less clear, and will depend on the technical ability to surveil and confirm the safety of IoT products. It will be difficult to rely on trusted suppliers, whether on the basis of nationality or territoriality, because of the complexity of production and the magnitude of risk. States will restrict imports and investment in connection with high risk IoT products under security exceptions in trade and investment law, although the specific language of those exceptions do not necessarily support such restrictions. In some circumstances, restrictions will be based on protectionism or geoeconomic considerations, rather than cybersecurity per se. In order to avoid inefficient restriction, states will find it useful to identify means to verify security of high risk IoT products, as well as to establish trust in producers of high risk IoT products, and on the basis of sufficient combinations of verification and trust, to relax their use of security exceptions.

Ratner: Global Investment Rules as a Site for Moral Inquiry

Steven R. Ratner (Univ. of Michigan - Law) has posted Global Investment Rules as a Site for Moral Inquiry (Journal of Political Philosophy, Vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 107-135, March 2019). Here's the abstract:
The legal regime regulating cross-border investment gives key rights to foreign investors and places significant duties on states hosting that investment. It also raises distinctive moral questions due to its potential to constrain a state’s ability to manage its economy and protect its people. Yet international investment law remains virtually untouched as a subject of philosophical inquiry. The questions of international political morality surrounding investment rules can be mapped through the lens of two critiques of the law – that it systemically takes advantage of the global South and that it constrains the policy choices of states hosting investment. Each critique contains certain moral and empirical assumptions that deserve further attention. The distributive justice implications of international investment rules are also relevant to scholars of global distributive justice. The aim of the analysis is to develop an interdisciplinary agenda – among law, philosophy, and social science – for inquiry into the justice of investment law and reform of its unjust elements.

Lieblich: Self-Defense Against Non-State Actors and the Myth of the Innocent State

Eliav Lieblich (Tel Aviv Univ. - Law) has posted Self-Defense Against Non-State Actors and the Myth of the Innocent State (in Global Governance and Human Rights, Nehal Bhuta & Rodrigo Vallejo eds., forthcoming). Here's the abstract:

Few contemporary debates on the use of force under international law have been more contentious than the argument over the lawfulness of transnational self-defense against non-state actors. In this context, especially controversial is the claim – advanced by the US and several other states – that defensive force against non-state actors could be lawful when territorial states are “unwilling or unable” to address the threat on their own.

Of the various objections to this standard, one significant argument suggests that when a territorial state is merely unable to stop a threat, any response against a non-state actor on its territory would be unlawful. This is because that state – assuming that it has exercised due diligence to prevent the threat – is at no fault; it has therefore not violated the prohibition on the use of force; and in the absence of such a violation, there can be no self-defense on its territory.

This Chapter challenges this argument. While not defending the lawfulness of the “unwilling or unable” test per se, it rejects the view that “state innocence” should be a valid objection to it. In this context, it argues that attributing overriding importance to state innocence conjures up an old anthropomorphism in international law, in which the state is conceived as a physical person, its territory akin to a human body. On this view, a response on the territory of an "innocent state" is likened to a response against the body of an innocent human threat or shield. Yet, in any legal regime that takes individual rights seriously, it seems that rights attributed to the fictionalized body of the state cannot override those of real-life people. It follows that state innocence alone cannot be a bar to self-defense against non-state actors, at least when human life is threatened by their attacks.

Tuesday, May 21, 2019

New Issue: Revue trimestrielle des droits de l'homme

The latest issue of the Revue trimestrielle des droits de l'homme (No. 118, 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • H. Labayle, Le Pacte mondial sur les migrations : un pacte avec le diable ?
  • G. Ravarani, Quelques réflexions sur la légitimité du juge de Strasbourg
  • C. Rizcallah, Le principe de confiance mutuelle : une utopie malheureuse ?
  • S. Wattier, La reconnaissance juridique du féminicide : quel apport en matière de protection des droits des femmes ?
  • C. Katz, Le refus de la protection des groupes politiques par la Convention sur la prévention et la répression du génocide : une exclusion contestable, une finalité entamée
  • T. Hochmann, Chronique des arrêts de la Cour suprême des États-Unis en matière de droits fondamentaux (octobre 2016 – juin 2018)
  • J. Arroyo, M-L. Basilien-Gainche, S. Lavorel, D. Mardon, C. Philippe, S. Turgis, S. Gerry-Vernières, A. Peyre, & A. Ailincai, La soft law dans le domaine des droits fondamentaux (octobre 2017 – octobre 2018)
  • X. Delgrange & D. Koussens, Quelles laïcités en salle d’audience ? À propos de quelques arrêts canadiens et européens sur le port de symboles religieux dans les prétoires
  • H. Tigroudja, Ports de signes religieux, « discrimination croisée » et ingérence de l’État dans la liberté de manifester sa religion
  • G. Haarscher, Le blasphémateur sous les fourches caudines des juges de Strasbourg
  • M-A. Beernaert, Droit d’accès à un avocat et relativité toujours plus grande des garanties du droit à un procès équitable
  • E. Patsrana & R. Bustos, « Bonne formation pour de bons jugements » - Le programme HELP (formation aux droits de l’homme pour les professionnels du droit) du Conseil de l’Europe

Call for Papers: ASIL Anti-Corruption Law Interest Group Works-in-Progress Conference

The Anti-Corruption Law Interest Group of the American Society of International Law has issued a call for papers for its first works-in-progress conference. The conference is cosponsored with the Faculty of Law at Ono Academic College and is organized in close cooperation with the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. The conference will take place in Kiryat Ono, Israel, on December 16, 2019. The call is here.

Monday, May 20, 2019

Call for Session Ideas: 2020 ASIL Annual Meeting

The American Society of International Law has issued a call for session ideas for its 114th Annual Meeting, which will take place April 1-4, 2020, in Washington, DC. The conference theme is: "The Promise of International Law." The deadline is July 16, 2019. Here's the call:

The Promise of International Law

In a world of increasing polarization and threats to individual and collective security, many turn to international law for guidance and protection, while others consider this body of law and the institutions that apply it ill-equipped to address evolving needs. Has international law lived up to its full potential and is it equipped to safeguard the peaceful coexistence of its subjects, to protect human rights and the environment, and to contribute to the attainment of shared prosperity?

The year 2020 will give us much to reflect upon and to reaffirm. Even as states have withdrawn or sought to withdraw from agreements such as the Trans-Pacific Partnership, the Paris Agreement on Climate Change, and the Treaty on European Union, the international community will commemorate other enduring institutions and commitments in 2020. For example, the United Nations will mark its 75th anniversary amidst calls for significant reforms to global governance. The year 2020 also will see the celebration of the 100th anniversary of the entry into force of the Treaty of Versailles and of the Covenant of the League of Nations, the 50th anniversary of the Declaration on Principles of International Law concerning Friendly Relations and Cooperation among States, and the 20th anniversary of UN Security Council Resolution 1325 on women, peace and security. At the same time, the year 2020 will serve as a reminder that we have but ten years left to achieve the UN Sustainable Development Goals, which envisage "a world of universal respect for human rights and human dignity, the rule of law, justice, equality and non-discrimination."

At its 114th Annual Meeting in 2020, the American Society of International Law (ASIL) invites policymakers, practitioners, academics, and students of international law to reflect upon the successes and failures of international law. Has international law held states, military forces, multinational corporations, and other actors – both public and private – to account for their international obligations? What role do regulatory bodies, international institutions, and non-governmental organizations play in actualizing the objectives of international law? Can and should international law be expected to produce just outcomes in all circumstances? The Annual Meeting presents an opportunity for the Society to take stock of the past successes and failures of international law while reaffirming the promise it holds for the future.

Thematic Tracks:

  • International Human Rights, Humanitarian Law, and Criminal Justice
  • Transnational Litigation, Arbitration, and Dispute Resolution
  • Trade, Investment, Finance, and Technology
  • Sustainable Development and Global Governance
  • Security, Foreign Relations, and Use of Force
  • Energy, Environment, Sea, and Space

Call for Session Ideas

To suggest a session to the Committee, please complete the form below by no later than July 16, 2019.

Click to Access Proposal Form

Mitchell & Mishra: Regulating Cross-Border Data Flows in a Data-Driven World: How WTO Law Can Contribute

Andrew D Mitchell (Univ. of Melbourne - Law) & Neha Mishra (Univ. of Melbourne - Law) have posted Regulating Cross-Border Data Flows in a Data-Driven World: How WTO Law Can Contribute (Journal of International Economic Law, forthcoming). Here's the abstract:
While the free cross-border movement of data is essential to many aspects of international trade, several countries have imposed restrictions on these data flows. The pre-internet rules of the World Trade Organization (‘WTO’) discipline some of these restrictions, but they are insufficient. Unfortunately, so are the electronic commerce chapters in modern preferential trade agreements. This article argues that reformed WTO rules, that take account of the policy challenges of the data-driven economy, are required. These reforms would facilitate internet openness while ensuring consumer and business trust, promote digital inclusion of developing countries and incorporate clear exceptions for legitimate domestic policies.

Yilma: The United Nations' Evolving Privacy Discourse and Corporate Human Rights Obligations

Kinfe Micheal Yilma (Addis Ababa Univ. - Law) has posted an ASIL Insight on The United Nations' Evolving Privacy Discourse and Corporate Human Rights Obligations.

SFDI: Santé et droit international : Colloque de Rennes

The Société Française pour le Droit International has published Santé et droit international : Colloque de Rennes (Pedone 2019). The table of contents is here.

New Issue: Human Rights Review

The latest issue of the Human Rights Review (Vol. 20, no. 2, June 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • Janet Elise Johnson & Xenia Marie Hestermann, How Human Rights Advocates Influence Policy at the United Nations
  • Won Geun Choi, Asian Civil Society and Reconfiguration of Refugee Protection in Asia
  • Stephen Arves & Joseph Braun, On Solid Ground: Evaluating the Effects of Foundational Arguments on Human Rights Attitudes
  • Cinthya Alberto & Mariana Chilton, Transnational Violence Against Asylum-Seeking Women and Children: Honduras and the United States-Mexico Border
  • Janne Mende, The Concept of Modern Slavery: Definition, Critique, and the Human Rights Frame

Sunday, May 19, 2019

New Issue: Transnational Legal Theory

The latest issue of Transnational Legal Theory (Vol. 10, no. 1, 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • Transnational Food Security
    • Domenico Giannino, Are we looking up or are we looking out? The transnational constitutionalism of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights: conventionality control and the fight against impunity
    • Samantha Besson, International courts and the jurisprudence of statehood
    • Paul Burgess, Deriving the international Rule of Law: an unnecessary, impractical and unhelpful exercise
    • Priya S. Gupta, The fleeting, unhappy affair of Amazon HQ2 and New York City
    • Stephen Minas, Why the ICJ’s Chagos Archipelago advisory opinion matters for global justice—and for ‘Global Britain’

New Issue: Global Trade and Customs Journal

The latest issue of Global Trade and Customs Journal (Vol. 14, no. 5, 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • Pratyush Nath Upreti, The Belt and Road Initiative at the Crossroads
  • Kishor Uprety, ‘OBOR’ an Internationalized Initiative for Integrated Development
  • Liao Li, The Legal Challenges and Legal Safeguards for the Belt and Road Initiative
  • Jiangyu Wang, China’s Governance Approach to the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI): Relations, Partnership, and Law
  • Shuang Liang, Discussion on Enhancing the Legal Cooperation of PPP Projects on the Platform of Belt and Road Initiative
  • M. Bart Kasteleijn, Legal and Economic Aspects of Chinese ‘Belt & Road Initiative’ Investments into Europe via the Netherlands
  • Peter K. Yu, China, ‘Belt and Road’ and Intellectual Property Cooperation
  • Bryan Mercurio & Dini Sejko, Holes in the Silk: Investor Protection under China’s Belt and Road Initiative
  • Tejeshwi Nath Bhattarai & Pratyush Nath Upreti, Navigating the Currents of Belt and Road Initiative: Perspectives on Least Developed Countries

Saturday, May 18, 2019

New Volume: Yearbook of International Environmental Law

The latest volume of the Yearbook of International Environmental Law (Vol. 28, 2017) is out. Contents include:
  • Emmanuella Doussis, Does International Environmental Law Matter in Sustainable Development?
  • Milan J N Meetarbhan, The 2010 Declaration of a Marine Protected Area around the Chagos Archipelago: Some Legal Reflections
  • Nick Monacelli, Food Security through Improved Enforcement Action against Illegal, Unreported, and Unregulated Fishing in the Western Pacific
  • Achinthi C Vithanage, A Deep Dive into the High Seas: Harmonizing Regional Frameworks for Marine Protected Areas with the UNCLOS Convention on the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Marine Biological Diversity in Areas beyond National Jurisdiction

Friday, May 17, 2019

New Issue: Harvard International Law Journal

The latest issue of the Harvard International Law Journal (Vol. 60, no. 1, Winter 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • Martha Minow, Do Alternative Justice Mechanisms Deserve Recognition in International Criminal Law?: Truth Commissions, Amnesties, and Complementarity at the International Criminal Court
  • Richard C. Chen, Precedent and Dialogue in Investment Treaty Arbitration
  • Ori Sharon, Tides of Climate Change: Protecting the Natural Wealth Rights of Disappearing States
  • C.J.W. Baaij, Hiding in Plain Sight: The Power of Public Governance in International Arbitration

Young: The Future of Economic and Social Rights

Katharine G. Young (Boston College - Law) has published The Future of Economic and Social Rights (Cambridge Univ. Press 2019). The table of contents is here. Here's the abstract:
The future of economic and social rights is unlikely to resemble its past. Neglected within the human rights movement, avoided by courts, and subsumed within a single-minded conception of development as economic growth, economic and social rights enjoyed an uncertain status in international human rights law and in the public laws of most countries. However, today, under conditions of immense poverty, insecurity, and political instability, the rights to education, health care, housing, social security, food, water, and sanitation are central components of the human rights agenda. The Future of Economic and Social Rights captures the significant transformations occurring in the theory and practice of economic and social rights, in constitutional and human rights law. Professor Katharine G. Young brings together a group of distinguished scholars from diverse disciplines to examine and advance the broad research field of economic and social rights that incorporates legal, political science, economic, philosophy and anthropology scholars.

Thursday, May 16, 2019

Rochow: Transnationale Nomaden im Völkerrecht

Moritz von Rochow has published Transnationale Nomaden im Völkerrecht (Duncker & Humblot 2019). Here's the abstract:
Dieses Buch untersucht, wie das Völkerrecht des 21. Jahrhunderts den Herausforderungen einer klimatisch bedingt mobilen Gesellschaft gewachsen ist und wie sich das Recht der Territorialstaaten mit dem Rule of the Clan nomadischer Völker versöhnen lässt. Noch bis zu Beginn des 20. Jahrhunderts war eine weltweite Freizügigkeit als Menschenrecht anerkannt und auch nomadische Völker hatten den Status von Völkerrechtssubjekten. Erstaunlicherweise sind mobile Völker seitdem nahezu ganz aus der völkerrechtlichen Literatur verschwunden. Diese Lücke schließt das Buch. Der Versuch, die Welt in ein Raster aus Territorialstaaten zu pressen, ist mit Blick auf jene Gemeinschaften, die auf ein unberechenbares Klima seit Jahrtausenden durch Migration reagieren, gescheitert. Dort, wo einst durch Europäer gezogene Linien postkolonial zu Staatsgrenzen erstarkt sind, geraten migrierende Menschen in Konflikt mit dem Territorialstaatsmodell, auf dem das heutige Völkerrecht aufbaut.

Voigt: International Judicial Practice on the Environment: Questions of Legitimacy

Christina Voigt (Univ. of Oslo - Law) has published International Judicial Practice on the Environment: Questions of Legitimacy (Cambridge Univ. Press 2019). The table of contents is here. Here's the abstract:
More and more environmental cases are being heard and decided by international courts and tribunals which lack special environmental competence. This situation raises fundamental questions of legitimacy of the environmental practice of international courts. This book addresses inter alia questions of who has legal standing to bring an environmental claim before an international court, on which legal norms is the case decided and whether judges have the necessary expertise to adjudicate environmental cases of often complex nature. It analyses which challenges international courts face, which possibilities they have and which advances international judicial practice has been able to make in protecting the environment. Through the prism of legitimacy important insights emerge as to whether international courts and tribunals are fit for addressing some of the most pressing global challenges of our time.

Peters: Humanisme, constitutionnalisme, universalisme : Etude de droit international et comparé

Anne Peters (Max-Planck-Institut für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht) has published Humanisme, constitutionnalisme, universalisme : Etude de droit international et comparé (Pedone 2019). Here's the abstract:
Le droit international et sa doctrine sont en pleine crise existentielle. C’est à leur chevet que se porte ce recueil d’articles signés par Anne Peters. Il faut repenser le droit international, écrit-elle. Pour cela, cependant, il faut repartir des fondamentaux, c’est-à-dire de l’épistémologie. Ici, les qualités et l’érudition de l’auteure comme internationaliste, constitutionnaliste et comparatiste apportent un regard original et très riche qui revisite non seulement le droit international mais également la manière dont il se pense. En particulier, l’auteure se livre à une critique des critiques faites au modernisme. S’il y a de vrais apports de la part de la critique post-moderne, elle y voit également des limites, contradictions et exagérations. Il faudrait donc tenir compte de ce mouvement pour le dépasser pour un « post-postmodernisme » qui emprunte ce qu’il y a de bon dans les divers courants de doctrine(s). Deux des directions proposées sont une nouvelle approche du constitutionnalisme mondial et une reformulation du droit international fondée sur le respect des droits de la personne humaine.

Call for Applications: Methodological Challenges in International Legal Research

The Chinese Initiative on International Law has issued a call for applications for junior scholars for a workshop on "Methodological Challenges in International Legal Research," July 11, 2019, in The Hague. The call is here.

New Issue: European Journal of International Security

The latest issue of the European Journal of International Security (Vol. 4, no. 2, June 2019) is out. Contents include:
  • Stefan Elbe & Gemma Buckland-Merrett, Entangled security: Science, co-production, and intra-active insecurity
  • Alexandria Nylen & Charli Carpenter, Questions of life and death: (De)constructing human rights norms through US public opinion surveys
  • Marc R. DeVore, Strategic satisficing: Civil-military relations and French intervention in Africa
  • Miguel Alberto N. Gomez, Sound the alarm! Updating beliefs and degradative cyber operations
  • Faye Donnelly & Brent J. Steele, Critical Security History: (De)securitisation, ontological security, and insecure memories
  • Alexander Lanoszka, Disinformation in international politics

Seibert-Fohr & Weniger: Compliance Monitoring under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights

Anja Seibert-Fohr (Universität Heidelberg - Law) & Christine Weniger (Universität Heidelberg - Law) have posted Compliance Monitoring under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Here's the abstract:
Despite their unequivocal international commitments, many States continue to neglect their human rights obligations domestically and do not give effect to human rights at the local level. The international community, once primarily concerned with the codification of human rights standards, has therefore accelerated its efforts to monitor and induce compliance over the past decades. The Human Rights Committee as a fundamental pillar of the UN Human Rights System has become a pioneer in this respect. As the main treaty body charged with monitoring the implementation of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights it was the first institution to introduce a follow-up procedure to its individual complaint mechanism. It subsequently extended this mechanism to the state reporting procedure and developed a grading scheme to assess the national measures taken in response to its recommendations. This article locates the follow-up procedures within the UN system, identifies the relevant stakeholders and explains the strategies to overcome resistance. In view of the Committee’s almost three decades long follow-up experience it is time now to take stock and evaluate this procedure in order to determine whether it has contributed to the compliance by States with their international human rights commitments. Based on the experience gained in the course of the follow-up proceedings and with compliance, more generally, we offer a critical evaluation of compliance monitoring and a perspective for future developments.